You could call it the magical mystery chord. The opening clang of the Beatles' 1964 hit, "A Hard Day's Night," is one of the most famous and distinctive sounds in rock and roll history, and yet for a long time no one could quite figure out what it was.
In this fascinating clip from the CBC radio show, Randy's Vinyl Tap, the legendary Guess Who and Bachman-Turner Overdrive guitarist Randy Bachman unravels the mystery. The segment (which comes to us via singer-songwriter Mick Dalla-Vee) is from a special live performance, "Guitarology 101," taped in front of an audience at the Glenn Gould Studio in Toronto back in January, 2010. As journalist Matthew McAndrew wrote, "the two-and-a-half hour event was as much an educational experience as it was a rock'n'roll concert."
One highlight of the show was Bachman's telling of his visit the previous year with Giles Martin, son of Beatles' producer George Martin, at Abbey Road Studios. The younger Martin, who is now the official custodian of all the Beatles' recordings, told Bachman he could listen to anything he wanted from the massive archive--anything at all.
Bachman chose to hear each track from the opening of "A Hard Day's Night." As it turns out, the sound is actually a combination of chords played simultaneously by George Harrison and John Lennon, along with a bass note by Paul McCartney. Bachman breaks it all down in an entertaining way in the audio clip above.
You can read about some of the earlier theories on The Beatles Bible and Wikipedia, and hear a fascinating account of one scholar's mathematical analysis of the component sounds of the chord from a few years ago at NPR.
Would you like to support the mission of Open Culture? Please consider making a donation to our site. It's hard to rely 100% on ads, and your contributions will help us continue providing the best free cultural and educational materials to learners everywhere.
Also consider following Open Culture on Facebook and Twitter and sharing intelligent media with your friends. Or sign up for our daily email and get a daily dose of Open Culture in your inbox.
Related Content:
Here Comes The Sun: The Lost Guitar Solo by George Harrison
Peter Sellers Reads "A Hard Day's Night" in Shakespearean Mode
Jimmy Page Tells the Story of Kashmir
There additional two other additional elements to the original chord, which actually features all four Beatles and George Martin.
If you listen carefully, the chord starts with the single strike of a snare drum, and George Martin plays a piano chord underneath as well.
Martin also doubled George Harrison’s guitar solo on piano, which is why it sounds the way it does.
Maybe that’s true, Dougald. Anyone who wants to learn about some of the various theories can follow the links in the last paragraph. But what Bachman is saying here is that he had an opportunity to listen to all the source material–to hear each of the component tracks in isolation–and that the chord breaks down as he says.
Mike
Cool. Thanks for sharing.
I just wonder if anyone who isn’t a baby boomer cares. (Since I *am* a boomer, I’m in no position to say.)
@Richard: oh yeah there are a lot of us (non baby boomers)who appreciate the magic and genius of the music and the era and movement it started. There are only so many firsts in the world and the Beatles were one of the pioneers of music. Whether people understand or want to understand how to make that first chord, once it’s played it resonates with a lot of people and just makes you wanna sing and play.
I think the music of the Beatles transcends generations somehow. It’s magic. I am a late Boomer (born 1963) and love their music, my youngest daughter born in 1991 has a tattoo’d Beatles sleeve and “All you need is love” tattoo’d on her back. Then again maybe it’s genetic. Nature vs nurture. whatever it is, that chord is awesome and totally unique. Thanks for sharing this!
Home boy hit the nail on the head. That’s that, next…
It’s a little more complicated than Mike Springer suggests. The song was originally recorded on a four-track recorder, and there were no “component” tracks of the individual instruments making that chord. The entire band was recorded on track 1, with vocals on track 2. Track three was acoustic guitar and percussion, and track 4 was the solo with guitar/piano. See Recording the Beatles book for more.
What Giles Martin apparently did for the One album and Cirque du Soleil show, was to use new digital technology that could separate the individual musical instrument components out of single tracks. This is how he was able to do the mashups on that album. Bachman mentions being invited to go and listen to the ProTools files.
Weez,
By “component tracks” I meant the individual tracks that make up the record. Nothing more. Thanks very much for the helpful input. (And for citing your source; it sounds like an interesting book.)
Best,
Mike
The Beatles have brought class and style to many generations. The Beatles at least for me can relate to today’s youth just like back then. Just my opinion.
Do younger people care about this or the Beatles in general? I’m 40, was born after The Beatles broke up and recognize their genius with regular plays of their albums. My SEVEN year old son loves them as well. A Hard Days Night being one of his favorite films and Beatles RockBand – we play as a family. The Beatles will live on.
I am a substitute teacher and from my experience most kids elementary school age love love love melodic music like the Beatles, the Beach Boys, Elvis, etc.
It’s when they get older in that terrible teen & pre-teen phase when they’re going through all those hormonal changes and they (most it seems) subconciously feel the need to totally overhaul practically everything they liked as a small child.
Many times I think it’s just an act of rebellion. You know the old adage: “You’re not suppose to like your parents music..it’s not cool.” And others simply succumb to peer pressure that permeates all around them.
I don’t have hard evidence to back this up, it’s just my determination from years of observation and interaction.
Here is a poor man’s version that we did back in the 1960s with a band I had.
Play B on the A string ( 2nd fret) and A ( second fret) on the G string. All other strings are open. On a 12 string it is fairly effective.
I have always thought it to be a Gm7 with some addition I can’t quite remember. In terms of “tab” from high “E” (1st string) 335353.
I was 11 when the Beatles appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show, and it was an absolute epiphany for me. I spent most of the rest of my life as a musician. There’s no doubt in my mind that George Martin was the 5th Beatle, and much more. The Hard Day’s Night chord was played by him, as well as the solo in the song. George would cover it live on a 12-string Rickenbacker. It’s a suspended 4th chord of some kind.
Martin knew of these “electric piano” sounds that were some kind of a cross between a piano and a harpsichord. I’m not sure where he got them, but there they are on the Beatles’ recordings, with Martin playing them so very tastefully.
E minor 7th sus4
That is the chord that the person said they played with the B on the A string and so on I hadn’t heard the video yet.
After hearing the video all the notes included would be GFACDand F# the latter producing the characteristic dissonance. Only my Opinion !
Another poor man’s approach is to learn the song in open D tuning and play the opening chord on the fifth fret as you would play an A7th chord in regular tuning, barring it, of course. It’s basic, but it works.
|—-3——————————————————–|
|—-3——————————————————–|
|—-5——————————————————–|
|—-3——————————————————–|
|—-5——————————————————–|
|—-3——————————————————–|
First, I love Randy and was fortunate enough to meet him in the 80s. But on the 1st chord of AHDN, there is absolutely a piano chord (played by GM), as stated by Doug L. in a previous reply I’ve been a collector and also have access to several of the isolated tracks. I just did a YT vid last week of the instrumental-only tracks of AHDN song (under “Louie Nye”) I also have alternate takes and studio chatter vids I made, as well.
What a revelation! Today’s digital technology is amazing. The chord I have played in the past was the one that Bobby B. tabbed above, which is a G7sus4. Does anyone know the piano chords hat George Martin played?
The G7sus4 is also the chord I still use to play AHDN!
saw the Beatles 150times at the Cavern and Paul gave me the chords to ‘Till there was you’ after they finished a session after John was er, busy putting a new string on. In early 61 Bob Wooler got me up and I sang 3 songs with the \Beatles, that was when Pete was still on drums. I sang 3 early Elvis songs as I knew George and John really rated early Elvis stuff and didn’t really dig his later stuff. My Aunt lived right opp Paul’s house in Forthlin road so I saw him quite a lot, the reason I saw them so much is because I knew they were gonna be the biggest thing ever, just knew it and I am blessed that I saw them so much and although they went on to conquer the world I am glad the world knew them as I did way back then
Noooo! all wrong completely. My mother , a Professor of Music worked with me on getting that chord immediately after getting the record in 64 and we played it that way always.Basically F6 triad with wrap over G muting A and open D on 12 string guitar. D7 sus4 played on 3rd fret for rhythm,Bass D+ Doctave played with plectrum,Strike on bell of large cymbal and hi tom rim shot. Piano is low chord same as 12 string chord with hi Dsus + F note. That,s it. Ending run out is F6 to F triad picked in arpeggio! So the sum of ‘THE CHORD’ is based around a D sus Chord and as D is the 5th, and dominant note of the G tonic scale it all makes sense. I play 26 instruments and have played since 1957 sooooo!??
So I listened to Randy now, and we totally agree!! We,ve been playing it Right for all these years. Good for u Randy. Dooley Mason comes from the same town in SA as me! We had great bands there in the 60,s!
Respect both RB and the Beatles….it still amazes me how many artists, song writers that were born after George and John passed away, still point to the Beatles as a major influence….
Interestingly enough, the guitar solo on this was too hard for george harrison to play, so they had to slow it down, then speed it up for the recording. So the solo is recorded a few steps down, then sped up to be both the correct speed, and in key.
Well, George Harrison would know it. And he has been recorded of stating it’s “an F with a G under” or in simple terms an Fadd9 (which is also used in the ending, alternating with a F chord). The trick is to play the bass F with the thumb and mute the A-string.
Fadd9 : 1X3213.
It’s close to the G7sus4 I have switched from playing that chord to an Fadd9.
So…….instead of all this conjecture,experimentation, gnashing of teeth and speculation over the years, why didn’t somebody just ask one of these guys how they did it? ;o)
Is it just me, or isn’t Randy’s chord quite different from the video chord? It sounds transposed.
Definitely a semitone higher.
The chord is an F Maj 2nd. It’s an F with a G note on top. I figured this out a long time ago and had it confirmed when I read an interview with John Lennon who says the same thing.
It’s impossible to reproduce without all the instruments, but the campfire version I have always used is: 5355333
In response to Steve: You can verify by comparing with other versions of the recording that the video embedded on thsi page is transposed because it is simply speeded up: the original 24 FPS film was played through a telecine at 25 FPS. Horrible as that is, it is the standard way to play film over television in countries with 50 Hz electrical power. That is unnecessary with online video, but whoever posted the YouTube video just used a dub made for TV, and didn’t know, or didn’t care.
@Christopher : you have a weird way naming chords. As far as I know, 2 and 4 are only used in chords where you change the 3rd to a 2 (sus2) or a 4 (sus4). Technically it’s a nine. It’s an added 9 because there’s no flatted 7th. I could be wrong, but a Major Chord would be a chord with a 7th (iso the standard flatted 7), minor chord is where the 3rd is flatted.
@Gerald : they did ask, and they both (apparantly, I only knew of George Harrison’s answer) state it’s a F with a G on top (a Fadd9). They both played the same chords, George on the 12 string Rick, John on his electo acoustic Gibson.
Back to the chord itself, the trick to the chord is the embedded C5 on top. This can both be found in the G7sus4 some prefer (but the open chord will sound a lot better than the barré, provided you fret it correctly) and the actual Fadd9. I bet you can just play the C5 to get the chime the chords evokes. I suspect an F5add9 would sound even better (1X3X13). The most important thing is to strike and fret it correctly, make sure you get the C5 (B and E string notes) to sound out.
this looks like an algebra exam!
As seen in a facebook post of Mike Isenberg:
“George Harrison described the chord himself – Bachman is wrong. I’ve studied The Beatles since 1963 and I’ll take George’s version any day. Here is the way it actually goes on the twelve string – anyone can do it and hear perfectly that it’s absolutely correct as George described it. Add onto it Paul’s bass note of D and George Martin’s piano chord and there you have it. Of course everyone will believe as they wish, but that IS the chord, and again, I’ll take George’s word over Randy Bachman, who doesn’t seem to add into the mix the fact that A Hard Day’s Night was recorded on a four track machine that would make it impossible to pull out separate tracks. Here is the chord – try it. You’ll hear the proof. First finger on the first fret of the sixth string. Second finger on the first fret of the second string (it’s a stretch). Little finger on the third fret of the first string. Strum all of the strings – and there you have it. It’s the same way George did the song in concert with The Beatles, and he said it was the same chord he used when they recorded the song.”
Essentially, Randy Bachman may or may not be accurate in saying how Giles Martin or someone else in post-Beatles times re-created the sound. But, he is certainly wrong in saying that what he describes is how The Beatles made the sound.
@George Nose : if you’re implying it’s 100013, that doesn’t make any sense. However if it’s 1XXX13, you get the F5add9 I mention and that does make an awful lot of sense as it’s basically two powerchords on top of each other (F5 and C5) and would sound like that. It’s not what notes are fretted, it’s what notes are actually played. I can imagine they muted the open strings with the index finger though.
I always thought it wa a dfad, not that i know anything about music, but from all i have read, thats what it is.
Fadd9/D
It’s not so much the chord itself that’s the mystery, but how it was voiced (especially with the 12 string). Cool stuff!
Always thought this song was in Bb. ;-)
There is a snare drum also with that chord.
Has anyone ever listened to the Beatle’s “Black Album”? It has a different version of A Hard Day’s Night on it. The solo is quite different.
I’ve been to your store serial times. Bought an Godin guitar from you several years ago. Loved that guitar. I’m ready for a Lavirree guitar now. I really love those guitars. I have a Taylor 410 and Martin D-18. I think the Lavirree beats both those guitars hands down. I’m looking for a L-03R or a L-05R. Can you help me out? Thanks..Mike
I think a lot of the general public havent heard all the wealth of obscure songs on any of the 4 lads albums . . . they never get played in Aus on mainstream radio . . . :)
Great work from Randy and answers a question for my band we’ve been asking for a while. What baffles me is that in the comments above there are still people demonstrating stupidity in maintaining their own wrong opinion about what the content of the chord should be while Randy was able to analyze the Original tapes. Shut up you guys and play it like Randy analyzed! Thanks Randy!
WOW!!! That’s AMAZING!!!
……I don’t think so Randy…………….
Duh, it’s a sus4 on the V in whichever key you choose to play it in.
Does anyone have access to the full video of this audio? It used to be on YouTube but got taken down. You can watch Randy build it.
It is odd that George disagrees, given that Randy & Giles went over all the layers on the tape…
http://www.mathstat.dal.ca/~brown/AHDNjib.html
I agree with bilrux……BIG DEAL…a sus chord….I really don’t care….I think now after all this I will go back to de-mystifying something useful.
headline should read “Giles Martin demystifies ……….. chord for randy Bachman……lol…..
Aaahh…folks? I think something that everybody is forgetting, is that what we hear as the final, recorded product, is usually a half-step to a full step higher than the original recording. The first thing that George Martin brought to the Beatles’ recording process (other than getting Pete best canned), was the classical recording trick of recording the original source at a slightly lower key and slower tempo, and then speeding up the tape for the final, master recording. So if you’re basing your analysis on the record, you’ll never get it right!
George Martin plays:
D2, G2, D3, G3 and C4 (middle C).
If you don’t play it that way on the piano, it will definitely sound like its missing something
Paul’s D is not open. It’s the fifth fret on The A string.
You guys are hilarious. A suspended 4th chord a Big Mystery to Rockin’ guitarists… “Ooooo, what is that Strange Sound?” Hahaha
Try listening to some Jazz. open up youre ears to something else besides 3 chord Rock tunes. Try a sharp 11 on for size. You’ll lose a little sleep for a few days, but it will be worth it!
yes ….. I was hoping someone would say what goog mead said so I wouldn’t have to.
Play the chords in the two videos.
They’re not even the same note.
What a complete waste of time.
Also, this long, incorrect interpretation also wrongly excludes the BASS and the DRUM, which contribute to the SOUND of the ORIGINAL CHORD.
This is the most intellectualized fail I’ve seen in a while. Congrats.
Putting all that together – D G C F A C G – makes Dm11 me thinks. Or F9/D or even Gsus9/D depending on the weather.
The chord is done on a 12 string electric and in standard tuning. High E third fret. B string first fret. Low E string 1st fret. A, D, and G string open. Don’t believe me but I have it in all my recorded tabs books.
Yes – we care!
“he had an opportunity to listen to all the source material–to hear each of the component tracks in isolation”
This is slightly over-stating things. The Beatles only had 2 tracks available to them in 1964. Sadly, they did not keep individual overdub tracks they used to build the songs. They recorded the instrumental section ‘live’, playing as a band, then added vocals and overdubs, layering onto two tracks. So “component tracks” as we understand them today are not really available.
Your absolutely correct. George Martin actually only played one note on the piano. The guitar chords are basically a G sus 4 chord over an F9 chord with George Martin letting the single A note sustain along with that guitars .
So it is G/D/F/C/D/G for the sus chord and G/F/A/C/G for the 9 chord,Lennon only played five notes. If you add the sustained acoustic piano note,that is what they did and it sounds like it …
I already replied …
In respect to what bag Martin played,I just listened again to the original UK stereo mix. It is in fact a D note he played. I knew it had to be an A or a D note. It is the D …
What I don’t understand is why people can’t accept the fact that it is the 12 string Rick playing the G7 sus 4 and John playing a six string F9, of F add the 9 ( G ) on top,as well as the bottom. The D and A notes are the difference …
I think it is every generation’s duty to somehow come up with something their parent’s will hate! Or even their older sibling.
Beatles, then, late 60’s rock, then punk, disco … eventually rap. PLEASE, where is the next generation? (but it rarely gets better, as you get older. You have to find your own music. I’m happily listening to so much new music. Americana, Irish, other music… I can hardly keep up with it!)
And it seems young people today want ‘the show’. They don’t care if anyone is playing, or even really singing. If they are happy with a floor show, it’s not for me to tell them they are wrong. Plenty of adults told me the Beatles were ‘wrong’. They changed my life! (but at 14, that didn’t take much!)
I still remember struggling with those Mickey Baker jazz books!
(RIP Dan Hicks!)
Wow.
This is why I read comments.
For all the negativity there is posted in comment sections across the internet, sometimes someone writes something as you did above which makes it all worth while.
Thank you for sharing your remembrances of a magical time.
Thanks David, that works well!
Well, with all the speculation…lets ask Paul
It’s quite simple and you can play bass note at the same time. 1st/John’s guitar didn’t make it to the final mix. Tune low E to D, then play Fadd9 tab=0 0 3 2 1 3
Whomever posted this video cut some of the dialog that Randy had about the different players and Dougald is right. George Martin played the piano part and doubled George’s solo.
I heard all of this on the original recording. He actually had every player play their part as he introduced it and then they all played it together.
All I remember was getting chills. That band was so freaky creative. I don’t think I could handle growing up without the Beatles. When I was 11 my brother shoved a guitar in my hands and said, “here, now you’ll never be a bore at parties”.
The original vid was about 7min.
Yes. I thought G-C-F-C-D-G
|—-3——————————————————–|
|—-3——————————————————–|
|—-5——————————————————–|
|—-3——————————————————–|
|—-3——————————————————–|
|—-3——————————————————–|
but it does appear to be a 3rd fret bar chord. The chord RB is suggesting is unplayable.
This is the ONLY way to play this chord if you have only one guitar at your disposal. It’s the only way to get all the notes of the chord in, including the lower A (open 5th string).
However, it’s not the way it was played in the studio. As others have correctly pointed out (and Randy Bachman, sadly, missed entirely), it’s a combination of all four Beatles plus George Martin playing very specific chords and notes.
The 353533 formation is a fudge if you’re playing out live, and is the closest combination you can get with a standard-tuning guitar (which you’ll obviously want to play the rest of the song!). But you’re still missing notes that are present in the chord if you only play this.
Note…I thought I was replying to Kim Shaheen’s message, but it didn’t appear below it. When I say the “this is the only way to play the chord on one guitar,” I’m referring to Kim’s method of tuning the low E string down to D and playing 003213.
But Melodyne makes it possible to isolate the different elements. I know it’s crazy, but that’s what they do now.
#11 and lydian mode in general is pretty damn common in pop music dude. Anyone who’s ever played an F on guitar has probably opened the B string up. I think perhaps you’re being a bit arrogant.
It’s a G7sus played in 3rd position. 353533.
I think Paul played the D in the bass up an octave
In respect to the opening chord of a HDN. I’m telling you exactly what it was. John was not playing a D suspended 4. Admittedly it sounded great,but was off a hair.
This is the breakdown.
George 12 playing a G sus 4
John F9 ( F chord with an added G on top and bottom )
George Martin did not play a chord.
Both him and Paul played a sustained D note . Just ONE sustained note,not a chord.
Obviously,the piano sustained ,much longer than Pauls note,but by Paul adding the D note as wel,it really packs a punch,on the attack.
Try this. You’ll love it.
The 60s were my formative years: jr. high, high school, and college and I learned to play guitar (only for myself!) via Beatles’ songs. I just spent some time Googling that chord and saw all sorts of variations. Last night I saw “1964 The Tribute” at a theater (they were note-for-note amazing). The four came out afterward to talk to us and I asked “John” about that chord (which they played during the concert). He said to Google Randy Bachman and “The Chord” which is how I got here. I should have just asked the three of them what they actually played for that chord last night. :)
goog mead and tix roger that.
lyrical as they were it was I think all by trial and error like all rock started. The ear knows what works even when the player can’t explain it all. pity all we get here is tab notation. These guys would die looking at some tatum or a ornette combos “chords” somebody said tatum could tell you the dominant and root in a toilet flush. after my first encounter with orntteI could not “hear: music for over a week. even kindergarden tune made no sense. that is transformation.
as for all the speed up eetc of the reecording gear. thats all seondary if you start with the relations and work back to transcribing so its playable on the frets . does no one own a spectrographic machine to look at whats actually there? and even the chimes can be sussed out if you filter the results by the reinforced timbres as they ring . is there a Tatum ear alive on the planet?
Fabulous Randy! Would have loved to hear you guys finish the whole song – cheers from a NZ Beatle fan
Plenty of songs have an opening chord or two that automatically identify them. “A Hard Day’s Night” is one of the best examples.
It’s the last chord that nobody plays right. It’s a F chord just listen very close. F chord with little finger hitting G letting up hitting F going back and forth. Try it hit the G then B sting then G again back and forth. Been playing that song for over 50 years. I’m 73 now. I like playing music the right chords. The right way. Thanks try it. Remember listen to the ending with earphones 🎸🎸👍👍
And yet, here you are saying it just the same.
George’s clanging chord served a radio purpose back in its time. It was a conversation stopper and Beatles’ fans immediately listened to the song. Dylan did something similar — but maybe not as effective — with the snare hit at the start of “Like a Rolling Stone”. Again, ideal for radio. There would be more throughout music history and I have heard Santana do something similar before some of their songs, usually with a combined guitar chord and a percussive strike.
The man said, it comes to a Dm11, which is the same as G7sus4/A (X00011).
I could agree except for F on the first, for me that must be a G.
After looking at Andy’s suggestion I’m convinced.
His chord and mine come very close, but I love all six strings better on Andy’s chord (although a bit harder for the thump). So that’s it: 100013 (or X00013, easy version).