Bertrand Russell on His Student Ludwig Wittgenstein: Man of Genius or Merely an Eccentric?

Even if you cultivate only a casual appreciation for philosophy, you’ll have realized that professional opinions differ about Ludwig Wittgenstein, and starkly. Philosophers don’t just argue about his work; they also seem to argue about his attitude, his conduct, his very person. Above, you can hear Betrand Russell, a somewhat less controversial philosophical personage, briefly give his impressions of the lad who would write the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus. (Find a copy in our Free eBooks collection.) You see, before landing in the philosophy track—or, in any case, his own crooked version of the philosophy track—Wittgenstein studied aerodynamics at England’s University of Manchester. An assignment in propeller design got him fascinated with mathematics, which led him to philosophy at Cambridge. There, in 1912 and 1913, he studied under Russell.

“He was queer, and his notions seemed to me odd,” Russell says, surely using queer in its archaic sense. (Though others do apply; in 1993, Derek Jarman made a gay-themed biographical film about the philosopher.) “For a whole term, I could not make up my mind whether he was a man of genius or merely an eccentric.” But at the end of this term, the young Wittgenstein brought to his instructor a pressing question: “Will you please tell me whether I am a complete idiot or not? If I am a complete idiot, I shall become an aeronaut; but, if not, I shall become a philosopher.” Russell issued a challenge to write about a philosophical subject over the school break, and Wittgenstein handed him the result as soon as the next term began. “After reading only one sentence,” recalls Russell, “I said to him, “No, you must not become an aeronaut.” And he didn’t.” One imagines his unrealized career in aeronautics wouldn’t have given us quite so much to debate.

Related Content:

Photography of Ludwig Wittgenstein Released by Archives at Cambridge

Listen to ‘Why I Am Not a Christian,’ Bertrand Russell’s Powerful Critique of Religion (1927)

Bryan Magee’s In-Depth, Uncut TV Conversations With Famous Philosophers (1978-87)

Colin Marshall hosts and produces Notebook on Cities and Culture and writes essays on literature, film, cities, Asia, and aesthetics. He’s at work on a book about Los Angeles, A Los Angeles Primer. Follow him on Twitter at @colinmarshall.



Make knowledge free & open. Share our posts with friends on Facebook, Twitter and other social media platforms:

by | Permalink | Comments (3) |

Choose a comment platform

Comments (3)
You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
  1. William Flintoff says . . . | March 8, 2013 / 4:23 pm

    Any discussion of Russell and Wittgenstein would benefit from reference to The World As I Found It, Bruce Duffy’s 1987 novel about Wittgenstein, Russell and G.E.Moore. It’s a beautifully written, 550 page philosophical novel that’s hard to put down. I hope that it will not fade from memory.

    Wm.Flintoff

  2. Steevithak says . . . | March 11, 2013 / 3:11 pm

    And don’t forget about Logicomix, the graphic novel about Russell’s life and philosophy. It describes the interactions between Russell and Wittgenstein too. I’ve not read “The World as I Found It” but it’s now on my reading list.

  3. Uwe says . . . | March 24, 2013 / 9:34 pm

    A curious anecdote: Russell and Whitehead approved Wittgenstein’s PhD thesis (the Tractatus) despite the fact that they were not smart enough to understand it. But to their credit– they were not so obtuse as to deny him tenure!

Add a comment

Loading Facebook Comments ...
Quantcast