What Makes Notre-Dame Cathedral a Masterpiece of Gothic Architecture

Most of us remem­ber where we were when we heard that Notre-Dame had burned down. And even upon learn­ing that the most famous of all French cathe­drals had been bad­ly dam­aged rather than com­plete­ly destroyed, it still felt as if some­thing irre­place­able had been lost. It made no dif­fer­ence whether we’d actu­al­ly been to the place, as I had­n’t at the time. When I did final­ly make it to Paris four years lat­er, Notre-Dame’s restora­tion was still under­way, and con­struc­tion walls pre­vent­ed any­one from see­ing much of any­thing at ground lev­el, let alone enter­ing. Yet crowds still gath­ered to take pic­tures in the square out­side, appar­ent­ly find­ing that prox­im­i­ty to such a civ­i­liza­tion­al land­mark was enough, even in its par­tial­ly ruined and inac­ces­si­ble state.

Even with­out a chance to step inside, expe­ri­enc­ing Notre-Dame’s sur­round­ings on the Île de la Cité, as well as the greater urban con­text of Paris, cer­tain­ly deep­ens one’s under­stand­ing of the beau­ty of the cathe­dral itself. So does vis­it­ing oth­er, less wide­ly known exam­ples of the form, as shown by archi­tec­ture-and-his­to­ry YouTu­ber Manuel Bra­vo in his new video above.

Ordi­nary tourists in Paris may make a bee­line for Notre-Dame, but they’re hard­ly like­ly to find their way out to the oth­er medieval cathe­drals in Saint-Denis, north of the city, much less all the way out in Laon. Though glo­ri­ous in their own way, they’re per­haps even more valu­able in pro­vid­ing the con­text of Goth­ic church archi­tec­ture in which Notre-Dame made such a mark.

As Bra­vo explains it, Notre-Dame’s façade rep­re­sents “the moment in which Goth­ic façade achieves its most bal­anced syn­the­sis. The exper­i­ments and inno­va­tions of Saint-Denis and Laon are absorbed, dis­ci­plined, and uni­fied into a com­po­si­tion in which no ele­ment appears arbi­trary or inde­pen­dent from the whole.” Among its most influ­en­tial appre­ci­a­tors was Vic­tor Hugo, in whose time much of Paris’ Goth­ic archi­tec­ture was being demol­ished. His roman­tic evo­ca­tions of the medieval built envi­ron­ment in Notre-Dame de Paris (in Eng­lish, The Hunch­back of Notre-Dame) helped save the much dete­ri­o­rat­ed tit­u­lar struc­ture, which received an ambi­tious ren­o­va­tion under Eugène Vio­l­let-le-Duc between 1844 and 1864. That project went beyond peri­od accu­ra­cy, adding such non-orig­i­nal details as the gallery of chimeras perched high enough to remain vis­i­ble dur­ing the lat­est restora­tion work. Vis­i­tors today may notice that the inte­ri­or does­n’t look exact­ly like it used to, but some will appre­ci­ate that even a mon­u­ment like Notre-Dame must change with the cen­turies.

Relat­ed con­tent:

The Cre­ation & Restora­tion of Notre-Dame Cathe­dral, Ani­mat­ed

A Vir­tu­al Time-Lapse Recre­ation of the Build­ing of Notre Dame (1160)

Notre Dame Cap­tured in an Ear­ly Pho­to­graph, 1838

An Archi­tec­tur­al Tour of Sagra­da Família, Antoni Gaudí’s Auda­cious Church That’s Been Under Con­struc­tion for 142 Years

How the World’s Biggest Dome Was Built: The Sto­ry of Fil­ip­po Brunelleschi and the Duo­mo in Flo­rence

Take a 3D Vir­tu­al Tour of the Sis­tine Chapel & Explore Michelangelo’s Mas­ter­pieces Up Close

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

The Amazing Inventions of Ancient Greece: From Plato’s Alarm Clock to Ancient Flamethrowers

“It’s a sun­ny morn­ing in ancient Greece. Stu­dents have start­ed gath­er­ing in the Acad­e­my, but their famous teacher Pla­to is nowhere to be seen.” The great philoso­pher has, it seems, “over­slept and missed his own lec­ture.” The sun and the sound of ear­ly-ris­ing ani­mals may have failed Pla­to that day, as the sto­ry goes, but nev­er would he let it hap­pen again — at least after he got the mech­a­nism worked out for the first alarm clock in his­to­ry. Its design involves a series of con­tain­ers linked by pipes through which water flows at a steady speed all night long. When the water accu­mu­lates in the penul­ti­mate, sealed ves­sel, air is pushed out through the flute embed­ded in its wall, pro­duc­ing some­thing like bird­song.

Pla­to’s water alarm clock is just one of the pieces of advanced ancient Greek tech­nol­o­gy explained in the new video above from Lost in Time, a YouTube chan­nel whose look at ancient Roman tech­nol­o­gy we post­ed here on Open Cul­ture last year.

Most of the oth­ers were invent­ed for less gen­tle pur­pos­es: we have a nasty-look­ing flamethrow­er on wheels meant to breach stone fortress­es; a “machine gun” able to fire arrows much more rapid­ly than any bow­man; a nine-sto­ry-tall pro­to-tank ful­ly stocked with cat­a­pults and sol­diers ready to swarm a city; and a gigan­tic claw, designed by no less a mind than Archimedes, able to grab and over­turn invad­ing war­ships. Yet as for­mi­da­ble as they sound, evi­dence of just how all these machines of war worked — and just how well they func­tioned in actu­al bat­tle — remains scarce.

Much clear­er are records of the Diolkos, recent­ly men­tioned here when we fea­tured the megapro­jects that even ancient Rome could­n’t pull off. Among those endeav­ors was a canal across the Isth­mus of Corinth, which would save ships hav­ing to take the long way around the Pelo­pon­nesian penin­su­la. Or rather, it would save them hav­ing to be dragged by a cou­ple hun­dred slaves over the Diolkos, a paved track­way built in the sixth cen­tu­ry BC. Using ramps and winch­es, ships could be shift­ed onto a wheeled cart that ran in grooves the whole way, mak­ing the whole sys­tem a pre­cur­sor of the rail­road, or per­haps an invert­ed ances­tor of the fer­ry still used to trans­port rail­way cars across the Strait of Messi­na. Like the Romans, the Greeks also con­sid­ered dig­ging a canal, but to do so might have vio­lat­ed the inten­tions of Zeus, a bet­ter excuse not to build infra­struc­ture than some of those we hear in the twen­ty-first cen­tu­ry.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

An Ani­mat­ed Intro­duc­tion to the Antikythera Mech­a­nism: The World’s First Ana­log Com­put­er from Ancient Greece

The Ancient Greek Water Clock That Kept the Most Accu­rate Time for 1,800 Years

Dis­cov­er the “Brazen Bull,” the Ancient Greek Tor­ture Machine That Dou­bled as a Musi­cal Instru­ment

How Ancient Greek Tech­nol­o­gy Was Used to Sculpt Mount Rush­more

Watch Art on Ancient Greek Vas­es Come to Life with 21st Cen­tu­ry Ani­ma­tion

How Ancient Greek War­ships Worked: The Engi­neer­ing of the Trireme Explained in 3D Ani­ma­tion

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

Watch Accurate Recreations of Medieval Italian Longsword Fighting Techniques, All Based on a Manuscript from 1404

Giv­en recent his­to­ry, the prospect of hun­dreds of young men meet­ing on Face­book, then trav­el­ing from around the coun­try to a cen­tral U.S. loca­tion might sound like rea­son­able cause for alarm. Yet a con­ven­tion fit­ting that descrip­tion had noth­ing to do with polit­i­cal vio­lence but, rather, a cel­e­bra­tion and appre­ci­a­tion of the name “Josh” (full dis­clo­sure: this writer did not attend). The gath­er­ing of the Josh­es in April 2021 in Nebras­ka could not have been more peace­ful, includ­ing its fin­ish­ing bat­tle royale, con­duct­ed with pool noo­dles.

The Josh­es had no con­cern for prop­er pool-noo­dle-wield­ing tech­nique, if there is such a thing. But groups of peo­ple who gath­er around the coun­try to stage medieval-style bat­tles in live-action role play­ing (LARP) games with weapons both real and fake might ben­e­fit from point­ers.

So, too, might those who chore­o­graph sword fights on stage and screen. Where can seri­ous his­tor­i­cal re-cre­ators learn how to wield a real blade in his­tor­i­cal­ly accu­rate com­bat? One resource can be found at Wik­te­nauer, a wiki devot­ed to col­lect­ing “all of the pri­ma­ry and sec­ondary source lit­er­a­ture that makes up the text of his­tor­i­cal Euro­pean Mar­tial arts (HEMA) research.”

The Fior di Battaglia (“Flower of Bat­tle”)—an Ital­ian fenc­ing man­u­al by Fiore de’i Liberi dat­ing from cir­ca 1404—offers rich­ly- and copi­ous­ly-illus­trat­ed demon­stra­tions of medieval Ital­ian longsword fight­ing tech­niques. In the orig­i­nal man­u­script, seen here and at The Get­ty, “the illus­tra­tions are inked sketch­es with gold leaf­ing on the crowns and garters,” notes the Wik­te­nauer entry. They dom­i­nate the text, which “takes the form of descrip­tive para­graphs set in poor Ital­ian verse, which are nev­er­the­less fair­ly clear and infor­ma­tive.” So clear, indeed, the brood­ing young men of Akademia Szermierzy—a Pol­ish group that recre­ates medieval sword-fight­ing techniques—can more than con­vinc­ing­ly mim­ic the moves in the video at the top.

Once they get going, after some req­ui­site pre-fight rig­ma­role, it’s impres­sive stuff, maybe already famil­iar to mod­ern fencers and cer­tain mem­bers of the Soci­ety for Cre­ative Anachro­nism, the LARP-ing orga­ni­za­tion of ama­teurs recre­at­ing every­thing from the Mid­dle Ages and the Renais­sance. But for those who think all live-action role-play­ing is the equiv­a­lent of the Bat­tle of the Josh­es (or off-brand Nazis run­ning through the streets in home­made armor), the sheer bal­let of his­tor­i­cal sword-fight­ing may come as a sur­prise — and maybe inspire a few more peo­ple to pull on the dou­blet and hose. See more medieval sword-fight­ing recre­ations from Akademia Szer­mierzy here, and the full text of the Fior di Battaglia here.

Note: An ear­li­er ver­sion of this post appeared on our site in 2021.

Relat­ed Con­tent: 

What It’s Like to Actu­al­ly Fight in Medieval Armor

A Close Look at Beowulf-Era Hel­mets & Swords, Cour­tesy of the British Muse­um

Renais­sance Knives Had Music Engraved on the Blades; Now Hear the Songs Per­formed by Mod­ern Singers

How Well Does Medieval Armor Actu­al­ly Stand Up to Medieval Arrows?: A His­tor­i­cal Re-Cre­ation Lets You See

The Last Duel Took Place in France in 1967, and It’s Caught on Film

Josh Jones is a writer and musi­cian based in Durham, NC. 

by | Permalink | Make a Comment ( 1 ) |

When Animals Were Put on Trial in Medieval Europe

Most of us twen­ty-first-cen­tu­ry urban­ites have a fair­ly sen­ti­men­tal view of farm ani­mals, pre­cise­ly because so many gen­er­a­tions have gone by since they’ve been part of our dai­ly lives. (In South Korea, where I live, the agri­cul­tur­al past remains just with­in liv­ing mem­o­ry. Per­haps that’s why so many restau­rants in Seoul adver­tise their meat with pic­tures of the ani­mals it comes from, some­times dressed in chef’s garb and cheer­ful­ly serv­ing up the very dish­es they’re about to become.) Things were dif­fer­ent in medieval Europe, where ani­mals were both a neces­si­ty and a poten­tial dan­ger. His­to­ry records many instances of seri­ous harm done to humans by hors­es, bulls, and espe­cial­ly pigs, who seem to have had a par­tic­u­lar ten­den­cy to turn on chil­dren.

Today we would describe the killing of a child as an inhu­man act, a term that, in these cas­es, applies more than fig­u­ra­tive­ly. As for the fate of the vio­lent­ly offend­ing ani­mal, we might imag­ine that it would be sum­mar­i­ly slaugh­tered, but between the tenth and eigh­teenth cen­turies — and espe­cial­ly in the fif­teenth and six­teenth cen­turies — it might well have been brought into a court­room first. Though oth­er crea­tures had already been sub­ject to legal pro­ceed­ings for quite some time, “the ear­li­est record­ed pig tri­al took place in Fonte­nay-aux-Ros­es, just out­side Paris, in 1266,” writes Alexan­der Lee at His­to­ry Today. “By the ear­ly fif­teenth cen­tu­ry, how­ev­er, they had become estab­lished prac­tice through­out Nor­mandy and the Île-de-France,” even­tu­al­ly spread­ing beyond the bor­der to Italy, Ger­many, and the Low Coun­tries.

“As con­tem­po­rary stu­dents of the Cor­pus iuris civilis knew, it was a basic prin­ci­ple of Roman law that ani­mals could not be cul­pa­ble,” Lee adds. “Lack­ing rea­son, they were inca­pable of har­bor­ing crim­i­nal intent and hence could not be guilty of a crime.” But in un-Roman north­ern France, “the admin­is­tra­tion of sec­u­lar jus­tice was still large­ly the con­cern of local seigneurs and was gov­erned pre­dom­i­nant­ly by cus­tom rather than statute.” Thus sus­tained, ani­mal tri­als served pur­pos­es beyond sim­ple pun­ish­ment. “For medieval peo­ple, the world was cre­at­ed by God in a very log­i­cal way, with ani­mals cre­at­ed first, in order to serve and help human beings who were cre­at­ed in the image of God,” says Uni­ver­si­ty of Liv­er­pool medieval Euro­pean mon­ster expert Dami­an Kempf, quot­ed in Pop­u­lar Sci­ence by Anne Ewbank. In that world­view, try­ing and exe­cut­ing a pig could “restore what was bro­ken.”

Unlike domes­tic ani­mals, accord­ing to Sonya Vatom­sky at JSTOR Dai­ly, destruc­tive mice, bee­tles, snails, wee­vils, and oth­er ver­min would be sent to eccle­si­as­ti­cal tri­bunals. “Despite being unlike­ly can­di­dates for Catholi­cism, such crea­tures were pun­ished with excom­mu­ni­ca­tion, not exe­cu­tion,” she writes, since cast­ing them out of God’s domain would allow humans to exter­mi­nate them with peace of mind. Vatom­sky also quotes econ­o­mist Peter T. Leeson’s the­o­ry that the Catholic Church tried more ani­mals when peo­ple got lax about tithing, with the aim of “bol­ster­ing cit­i­zens’ belief in the valid­i­ty of Church pun­ish­ments for tithe eva­sion.” Putting ani­mals on tri­al may now strike us as grotesque, but like any alien-seem­ing episode of his­to­ry, it also reveals the beliefs on which a past soci­ety oper­at­ed — a mode of analy­sis that gets one won­der­ing how far the mod­ern Unit­ed States is from giv­ing them the right to sue.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Why Ani­mals Look So Strange in Medieval Man­u­scripts

1,000 Years of Medieval Euro­pean His­to­ry in 20 Min­utes

The Aberdeen Bes­tiary, One of the Great Medieval Illu­mi­nat­ed Man­u­scripts, Now Dig­i­tized in High Res­o­lu­tion & Made Avail­able Online

A Free Yale Course on Medieval His­to­ry: 700 Years in 22 Lec­tures

Cats in Medieval Man­u­scripts & Paint­ings

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

2,800-Year-Old Bone Flute Unearthed in Troy May Have Been Played During Homer’s Time

Image by Mehmet Nuri Ersoy, via Twit­ter

The pro­lif­ic Hans Zim­mer scored Christo­pher Nolan’s films over the dozen years from Bat­man Begins through Dunkirk. From 2020’s Tenet onward, Nolan has employed the younger Swedish com­pos­er Lud­wig Görans­son. Just what dif­fer­ence this has made in the result­ing pic­tures is a mat­ter best left to the scruti­ny of the most obses­sive fans, but any view­er can hear how much Zim­mer and Görans­son dif­fer styl­is­ti­cal­ly. This past sum­mer, the siren song includ­ed on the sound­track of The Odyssey fea­tured one of the lat­ter’s par­tic­u­lar­ly notable choic­es: the use of an aulos, a dou­ble-reed­ed wind instru­ment much played back in ancient Greece.

Though Görans­son did­n’t have a gen­uine­ly ancient aulos on hand, of course, the sound pro­duced by the repli­ca proved evoca­tive enough. But just this year, as it hap­pens, a bone flute actu­al­ly dat­ing from the peri­od in which Homer wrote The Odyssey was unearthed from the archae­o­log­i­cal site of ancient Troy in mod­ern-day north­west­ern Turkey.

As Smithsonian.com’s Meilan Sol­ly writes, the past 160 years of dig­ging there have pro­duced “a pair of gold diadems, more than 100 two-han­dled wine gob­lets, and arrow­heads and weapons dat­ed to the Late Bronze Age, among oth­er arti­facts.” This 2,800-year-old flute isn’t just the first musi­cal instru­ment dis­cov­ered at the site, but also fur­ther evi­dence that Troy was­n’t the ghost town it was once assumed to be in the eighth cen­tu­ry BC.

As always when deal­ing with ancient arti­facts — and espe­cial­ly ones, as these pic­tures reveal, in a less-than-whole state — we should be care­ful with our terms. “Call­ing the object a flute is the exca­va­tors’ choice of word, and the type remains open,” says Ancient Ori­gins. While this new dis­cov­ery could poten­tial­ly be a real Greek aulos, “with­out hole counts or a pub­lished draw­ing, match­ing the Troy find to that design is pre­ma­ture.” Archae­ol­o­gists have unearthed sim­i­lar instru­ments else­where, dat­ing from dif­fer­ent peri­ods, but nev­er before has one emerged from the buried remains of a city so rich in leg­endary asso­ci­a­tions. To those in search of a deep­er under­stand­ing of antiq­ui­ty, the site con­tin­ues to sound a siren song of its own.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Hear What Homer’s Odyssey Sound­ed Like When Sung in the Orig­i­nal Ancient Greek

Bronze Age Britons Turned Bones of Dead Rel­a­tives into Musi­cal Instru­ments & Orna­ments

Hear a 9,000 Year Old Flute—the World’s Old­est Playable Instrument—Get Played Again

Hear a Recent­ly-Dis­cov­ered 12,000-Year-Old Flute That Musi­cal­ly Mim­ics the Sound of Rap­tor Calls

What Ancient Greek Music Sound­ed Like: Lis­ten to a Recon­struc­tion That’s “100% Accu­rate”

Hear the World’s Old­est Instru­ment, the “Nean­derthal Flute,” Dat­ing Back Over 43,000 Years

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

Watch Seoul’s 6,500-Year Evolution in a Mesmerizing 3D Animated Time Lapse

In this cen­tu­ry, few coun­tries have been as vis­i­bly suc­cess­ful as South Korea. Chi­na’s ver­tig­i­nous eco­nom­ic rise once absorbed vast amounts of news-media atten­tion, but its soft pow­er has com­par­a­tive­ly lit­tle reach across the wider world, at least in Eng­lish-speak­ing coun­tries. By this point, many if not most West­ern­ers haven’t just eat­en Kore­an food, but also dri­ven a Kore­an car, heard Kore­an pop music, or watched a Kore­an film or TV show. The result­ing sense of famil­iar­i­ty can prove decep­tive to those who even­tu­al­ly make the trip there, but it does, at least, mark an improve­ment on the scant knowl­edge of the place they had before. Not so long ago, they could say lit­tle with cer­tain­ty except this: South Kore­a’s got Seoul.

I first saw that pun on a T‑shirt in high school, long before I knew much of any­thing about Korea myself. Now, hav­ing lived there for more than a decade, I’ve been able to watch from the inside as the coun­try’s cap­i­tal has become an unlike­ly object of gen­er­al inter­est. As evi­dence, take the 1.2 mil­lion views already racked up by the new video from Latos Charts above, a 3D ani­mat­ed time lapse show­ing the evo­lu­tion of Seoul over six and a half often tumul­tuous mil­len­nia.

It reveals, among oth­er things, that the city did­n’t exist for most of the his­to­ry of Kore­an civ­i­liza­tion — but then, nei­ther did the coun­try. The post­war divi­sion of the penin­su­la into North and South has a kind of prece­dent in the war­ring king­doms that occu­pied it before its uni­fi­ca­tion by a series of states cul­mi­nat­ing in the 500-year rule of the Joseon Dynasty.

If you’ve watched one of the many pop­u­lar his­tor­i­cal “K‑dramas,” Joseon was most like­ly its peri­od set­ting. Now gen­er­al­ly regard­ed as the pre­de­ces­sor of mod­ern-day Korea, it pass­es in two min­utes of the time lapse, dur­ing which Seoul, then known as Hanyang, takes amid its geo­man­ti­cal­ly pro­tec­tive moun­tains more or less the shape it has today, at least north of the Han Riv­er. In fact, up until the sev­en­ties, there was no city to speak of south of the Han: the devel­op­ment of the more recent­ly musi­cal­ly sat­i­rized Gang­nam, lit­er­al­ly “south of the riv­er,” was part of the top-down push for eco­nom­ic devel­op­ment — in effect, hit­ting the fast-for­ward but­ton on his­to­ry — that fol­lowed the dev­as­ta­tion of the Kore­an War. That chap­ter of his­to­ry comes around eight min­utes into the video, after which looka­like high-rise com­plex­es start pop­ping up like mush­rooms after a mon­soon.

How­ev­er com­fort­able a lifestyle they’ve offered to mid­dle-class Seoulites, the sight of those apa­teu dan­ji unset­tles some West­ern observers, who encounter them in pho­tographs meant to depict the city as a kind of futur­is­tic dystopia. They exag­ger­ate, of course, but even some­one who appre­ci­ates Seoul as much as I do has to admit that, along­side its impres­sive qual­i­ties — the mag­nif­i­cent sub­way sys­tem, for exam­ple, extolled in the Not Just Bikes video above — the city has its prob­lems, as does the nation for which it stands. Under­stand­ing it in all its com­plex­i­ty requires first (even before learn­ing the Kore­an lan­guage) grasp­ing its sheer cen­tral­i­ty, greater than Toky­o’s to Japan or even Paris’ to France. To a great extent, South Korea has­n’t just got Seoul, it is Seoul. And maybe, if its promi­nence in the wider world con­tin­ues to grow, the pun­ning will even­tu­al­ly stop. In Kore­an his­to­ry, stranger things have cer­tain­ly hap­pened.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Watch the Evo­lu­tion of Man­hat­tan Unfold in a Time­lapse Video, from 1600 to 2026

Watch the Evo­lu­tion of Paris Unfold in a Time­lapse Video, from 300 BCE to 2025

Watch Rome Rise, Fall, and Rise Again in a Three-Minute 3D Time­lapse

Why the Maps of Lon­don, Tokyo, New York, and Oth­er Major Cities Look the Way They Do

Time­lapse Ani­ma­tion Lets You See the Rise of Cities Across the Globe, from 3700 BC to 2000 AD

Learn the Kore­an Lan­guage with Hun­dreds of Episodes of Let’s Speak Kore­an Free Online

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

The Painting Nobody Wanted: How Matisse’s The Red Studio Went from a London Nightclub to a Masterpiece of Modern Art

A jour­nal­ist paid Hen­ri Matisse a vis­it not long after he’d paint­ed The Red Stu­dio in 1911. “I like it, but I don’t com­plete­ly under­stand it,” the artist is quot­ed as admit­ting of that lat­est work. “I like it, but I don’t know why I pre­cise­ly paint­ed it this way.” The paint­ing was a ren­di­tion of the very same Issy-les-Moulin­eaux stu­dio in which they were talk­ing, though you would­n’t nec­es­sar­i­ly rec­og­nize it at first glance. Deep red cov­ered two-thirds of its sur­face, an unortho­dox choice that prob­a­bly con­tributed to its rejec­tion by Matis­se’s loy­al patron Sergei Shchukin, who’d com­mis­sioned Dance and Music. This depar­ture from strict rep­re­sen­ta­tion fared no bet­ter when it was shown in Lon­don, and there­after at the ground­break­ing 1913 “Armory Show” in the Unit­ed States.

By 1926, when The Red Stu­dio final­ly made its Paris debut, pub­lic sen­si­bil­i­ties had begun to catch up with Matis­se’s instincts. The fol­low­ing year, it found a buy­er in the own­er of Lon­don’s Gar­goyle Club, a favorite haunt of the Bright Young Things, where the paint­ing would hang for more than a decade.

Even­tu­al­ly it end­ed up at the Muse­um of Mod­ern Art, whose video at the top of the post tells the sto­ry of the paint­ing’s jour­ney from endur­ing absolute rejec­tion to exert­ing great influ­ence on post­war New York artists like Mark Rothko, Bar­nett New­man, and Ellsworth Kel­ly. All of those younger painters were explor­ing the pos­si­bil­i­ties of what MoMA cura­tor Ann Temkin calls “a big expanse of col­or that does­n’t describe any­thing, that just is there for its own expres­sive pur­pos­es.”

Gal­lerist-YouTu­ber James Payne explores the paint­ing’s evo­lu­tion in greater detail  in his new Great Art Explained video above. But this image, which “seemed to break almost every estab­lished rule of West­ern paint­ing,” did­n’t come out of nowhere. Around the turn of the twen­ti­eth cen­tu­ry, sci­en­tif­ic and tech­no­log­i­cal devel­op­ments were chang­ing human­i­ty’s under­stand­ing of real­i­ty, while Paris was becom­ing espe­cial­ly fer­tile ground for new ideas about art, per­cep­tion, and rep­re­sen­ta­tion. Inspired by a vari­ety of oth­er Euro­pean artists and, increas­ing­ly, for­eign cul­tures as well, Matisse had already made his mark as one of the so-called Fau­vists, a group of painters who ont épaté la bour­geoisie with their bold, delib­er­ate­ly non-real­is­tic use of col­or. Fol­low­ing his instincts from there, Matisse cre­at­ed this scene awash in red and bereft of any human pres­ence — and in so doing, as Payne explains while exam­in­ing it object by object and art­work by art­work, cre­at­ed what may well be his great­est self-por­trait.

Relat­ed con­tent:

How Hen­ri Matisse Scan­dal­ized the Art Estab­lish­ment with His Dar­ing Use of Col­or

Hen­ri Matisse Illus­trates James Joyce’s Ulysses (1935)

When Hen­ri Matisse Was 83 Years Old, He Couldn’t Go to His Favorite Swim­ming Pool, So He Cre­at­ed a Swim­ming Pool as a Work of Art

Hen­ri Matisse Illus­trates Baudelaire’s Cen­sored Poet­ry Col­lec­tion Les Fleurs du Mal

Van Gogh’s Ugli­est Mas­ter­piece: A Break­down of His Late, Great Paint­ing, The Night Café (1888)

Watch Icon­ic Artists at Work: Rare Videos of Picas­so, Matisse, Kandin­sky, Renoir, Mon­et, Pol­lock & More

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

When Charles Dickens Met Edgar Allan Poe

“There comes Poe with his raven,” wrote the poet James Rus­sell Low­ell in 1848, “like Barn­a­by Rudge, / Three-fifths of him genius and two-fifths sheer fudge.” Barn­a­by Rudge, as you may know, is a nov­el by Charles Dick­ens, pub­lished seri­al­ly in 1841. Set dur­ing the anti-Catholic Gor­don Riots of 1780, the book stands as Dick­ens’ first his­tor­i­cal nov­el and a pre­lude of sorts to A Tale of Two Cities. But what, you may won­der, does it have to do with Poe and “his raven”?

Quite a lot, it turns out. Poe reviewed the first four chap­ters of Dick­ens’ Barn­a­by Rudge for Graham’s Mag­a­zine, pre­dict­ing the end of the nov­el and find­ing out lat­er he was cor­rect when he reviewed it again upon com­ple­tion. He was par­tic­u­lar­ly tak­en with one char­ac­ter: a chat­ty raven named Grip who accom­pa­nies the sim­ple-mind­ed Barn­a­by. Poe described the bird as “intense­ly amus­ing,” points out Atlas Obscu­ra, and also wrote that Grip’s “croak­ing might have been prophet­i­cal­ly heard in the course of the dra­ma.”

It chanced the fol­low­ing year the two lit­er­ary greats would meet, when Poe learned of Dick­ens’ trip to the U.S.; he wrote to the nov­el­ist, and the two briefly exchanged let­ters (which you can read here). Along with Dick­ens on his six-month jour­ney were his wife Cather­ine, his chil­dren, and Grip, his pet raven. When the two writ­ers met in per­son, writes Lucin­da Hawk­sley at the BBC, Poe “was enchant­ed to dis­cov­er [Grip, the char­ac­ter] was based on Dickens’s own bird.”

Indeed Dick­ens’ raven, “who had an impres­sive vocab­u­lary,” inspired what Dick­ens called the “very queer char­ac­ter” in Barn­a­by Rudge, not only with his loqua­cious­ness, but also with his dis­tinc­tive­ly ornery per­son­al­i­ty. Dick­ens’ daugh­ter Mamie described the raven as “mis­chie­vous and impu­dent” for its habit of bit­ing the chil­dren and “dom­i­nat­ing” the family’s mas­tiff, such that the bird was ban­ished to the car­riage house.

grip-the-raven

Image cour­tesy of the Free Library of Philadel­phia.

But Dickens—who Jonathan Lethem calls the “great­est ani­mal nov­el­ist of all time”—loved the bird, so much that he wrote mov­ing­ly and humor­ous­ly of Grip’s death, and had him stuffed. (A not unusu­al prac­tice for Dick­ens; we’ve pre­vi­ous­ly fea­tured a let­ter open­er Dick­ens had made from the paw of his cat, Bob.)  The remains of the his­tor­i­cal Grip now reside in the rare book sec­tion of the Free Library of Philadel­phia, “a stuffed raven” writes The Wash­ing­ton Post’s Ray­mond Lane, “about the size of a big cat.” (See Grip above.)

Of the lit­er­ary Grip’s influ­ence on Poe, Janine Pol­lack, head of the library’s rare books depart­ment, tells Philadel­phia mag­a­zine, “It is sort of a unique moment in lit­er­a­ture when these two great writ­ers are sort of think­ing about the same thing. You think about how much the two men were look­ing at each other’s work. It’s almost a col­lab­o­ra­tion with­out them real­iz­ing it.” But can we be sure that Dick­ens’ Grip, real and imag­ined, direct­ly inspired Poe’s “The Raven”? “Poe knew about it,” says his­to­ri­an Edward Pet­tit, “He wrote about it. And there’s a talk­ing raven in it. So the link seems fair­ly obvi­ous to me.”

Lane adduces some clear evi­dence of pas­sages in the nov­el that sound very much like Poe: “At the end of the fifth chap­ter,” for exam­ple, “Grip makes a noise and some­one asks, ‘What was that—him tap­ping at the door?’ Anoth­er char­ac­ter responds, ‘’Tis some­one knock­ing soft­ly at the shut­ter.’” Hawk­sley notes even more sim­i­lar­i­ties. “Although there is no con­crete proof,” she writes, “most Poe schol­ars are in agree­ment that the poet’s fas­ci­na­tion with Grip was the inspi­ra­tion for his 1845 poem The Raven.”

Where we often find sur­pris­ing lin­eages of influ­ence from author to author, it’s unusu­al that the con­nec­tions are so direct, so per­son­al, and so odd, as those between Poe, Dick­ens, and Grip the talk­ing raven. I’m espe­cial­ly struck by an irony in this sto­ry: Poe court­ed Dick­ens in 1842 “to impress the nov­el­ist,” writes Sid­ney Moss of South­ern Illi­nois Uni­ver­si­ty, “with his worth and ver­sa­til­i­ty as a crit­ic, poet, and writer of tales,” and with the aim of estab­lish­ing a lit­er­ary rep­u­ta­tion, and pub­lish­ing con­tracts, in Eng­land.

While Dick­ens seemed duly impressed, and will­ing to help, noth­ing com­mer­cial came of their exchange. Instead, Dick­ens and his raven inspired Poe to write the most famous poem of his life, “The Raven,” for which he will be remem­bered forever­more.

Note: An ear­li­er ver­sion of this post appeared on our site in 2016.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Explore an Online Archive of 2,100+ Rare Illus­tra­tions from Charles Dick­ens’ Nov­els

Charles Dick­ens Gave His Cat “Bob” a Sec­ond Life as a Let­ter Open­er

The His­toric Meet­ing Between Dick­ens and Dos­to­evsky Revealed as a Great Lit­er­ary Hoax

Édouard Manet Illus­trates Edgar Allan Poe’s The Raven, in a French Edi­tion Trans­lat­ed by Stephane Mal­lar­mé (1875)

Josh Jones is a writer and musi­cian based in Durham, NC. 

by | Permalink | Make a Comment ( 2 ) |

More in this category... »
Quantcast