The Directing Genius of Akira Kurosawa Explained

Gen­er­a­tions of West­ern­ers have come to appre­ci­ate Japan­ese cin­e­ma through the films of Aki­ra Kuro­sawa, but many have been shocked to find out that Kuro­sawa him­self isn’t as beloved in Japan as they’d imag­ined. It’s less that his home­land rejects him than that his work has been regard­ed there as a some­what for­eign taste. That judg­ment must have some­thing to it: despite their thor­ough­ly Japan­ese set­tings, Throne of Blood, The Bad Sleep Well, and Ran were, after all, Shake­speare adap­ta­tions, and Kuro­sawa spoke open­ly of struc­tur­ing his sto­ries in the man­ner of not just tra­di­tion­al Japan­ese the­ater, but also sym­phonies. Con­sid­er, too, the way his films con­tin­ue to inspire West­ern remakes, from The Mag­nif­i­cent Sev­en and A Fist­ful of Dol­lars in the nine­teen-six­ties to Liv­ing and High­est 2 Low­est in this decade.

Nor can it be a coin­ci­dence that the appre­cia­tive voic­es open­ing the Stu­dioBinder video on Kuro­sawa’s genius above belong to Steven Spiel­berg, Mar­tin Scors­ese, and George Lucas. Yet this most inter­na­tion­al­ly cel­e­brat­ed of all Japan­ese film­mak­ers can’t, ulti­mate­ly, have been just a West­ern­er in dis­guise, since his work gives view­ers around the world some­thing that their domes­tic movies don’t.

What­ev­er the extent to which he hybridized the cin­e­mat­ic sen­si­bil­i­ties of Japan and Hol­ly­wood, he did so through his uncom­pro­mis­ing per­son­al involve­ment in every stage of the process. “The role of the direc­tor encom­pass­es the coach­ing of the actors, the cin­e­matog­ra­phy, the sound record­ing, the art direc­tion, the music, the edit­ing, and the dub­bing and sound mix­ing,” he once said, express­ing his ded­i­ca­tion to the ide­al of (as no less an Amer­i­can auteur than Jer­ry Lewis described him­self) the total film­mak­er.

That Kuro­sawa under­stood how to tell a sto­ry in a way that tran­scends cul­tur­al bound­aries goes with­out say­ing; what’s less wide­ly appre­ci­at­ed is the way he did so with a com­bi­na­tion of sim­plic­i­ty and com­plex­i­ty. As he put it, “a tru­ly good movie is inter­est­ing and easy to under­stand,” two qual­i­ties that often end up in irre­solv­able ten­sion, at least in the hands of less­er film­mak­ers. Even among those influ­enced by Kuro­sawa, for exam­ple, some have mas­tered imme­di­ate visu­al leg­i­bil­i­ty with­out ever under­stand­ing that sound and music are more effec­tive­ly used as a coun­ter­point to, rather than mere inten­si­fi­ca­tion of, a scene’s pre­vail­ing emo­tion. How many liv­ing direc­tors, for that mat­ter, con­vinc­ing­ly approach grand, uni­ver­sal themes with­out irony or pro­tec­tive dis­tance? If Kuro­sawa’s films retain a pow­er that seems inac­ces­si­ble today, it may be because, for him, there was no East or West: there was only cin­e­ma.

Relat­ed Con­tent

The Gold­en Age of Japan­ese Cin­e­ma: Kuro­sawa, Ozu, Mizoguchi & Beyond

How Did Aki­ra Kuro­sawa Make Such Pow­er­ful & Endur­ing Films? A Wealth of Video Essays Break Down His Cin­e­mat­ic Genius

How Aki­ra Kuro­sawa Used Move­ment to Tell His Sto­ries: A Video Essay

The Geo­met­ric Beau­ty of Aki­ra Kuro­sawa and Wes Anderson’s Films

Aki­ra Kurosawa’s Advice to Aspir­ing Film­mak­ers: Write, Write, Write and Read

The Paint­ings of Aki­ra Kuro­sawa

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

Explore 250,000 Articles from Salon’s 31-Year History at the Internet Archive

Ear­li­er this month, Salon announced that it’s ceas­ing pub­li­ca­tion after 31 years. In its farewell address, the mag­a­zine writes: “The busi­ness real­i­ties of inde­pen­dent dig­i­tal jour­nal­ism have changed pro­found­ly over the years. After care­ful con­sid­er­a­tion, we have reached the dif­fi­cult deci­sion that our pub­lish­ing mod­el is no longer sus­tain­able.” We can sym­pa­thize.

Over the 20 years we have served you, we have watched qual­i­ty web­sites come and go. Some once-vibrant sites have gone entire­ly dark. Today, if you want to sift through the remains of the ear­ly inter­net, you can head over to the Inter­net Archive—a site that “cap­tures and stores over one tril­lion web pages to safe­guard dig­i­tal his­to­ry and pre­vent the rewrit­ing or era­sure of online records.” In the case of Salon, the Inter­net Archive has launched Salon Explor­er, a “new inter­face for dis­cov­er­ing Salon’s archived jour­nal­ism.” Accord­ing to a new blog post from the Inter­net Archive, the tool lets you browse more than 250,000 arti­cles and explore the work of over 20,000 writ­ers, with fil­ters that make it eas­i­er to find sto­ries you may have missed. If it isn’t your pre­ferred inter­face, you can also browse Salon.com using the Way­back Machine. RIP Salon, long live the Inter­net Archive.

Enter the Salon Explor­er here.

If you would like to sup­port the mis­sion of Open Cul­ture, con­sid­er mak­ing a dona­tion to our site. It’s hard to rely 100% on ads, and your con­tri­bu­tions will help us con­tin­ue pro­vid­ing the best free cul­tur­al and edu­ca­tion­al mate­ri­als to learn­ers every­where. You can con­tribute through Pay­Pal, Patre­on, and Ven­mo (@openculture). Thanks!

via Kot­tke

Relat­ed Con­tent 

10,000 Chica­go Con­cert Record­ings Are Being Uploaded to the Inter­net Archive: Nir­vana, Phish, Son­ic Youth, They Might Be Giants & More

The Inter­net Archive Res­cues MTV News’ Web Site, Mak­ing 460,000+ of Its Pages Search­able Again

A Free Dig­i­tal Archive of Graph­ic Design: A Curat­ed Col­lec­tion of Design Trea­sures from the Inter­net Archive

How the Inter­net Archive Dig­i­tizes 3,500 Books a Day–the Hard Way, One Page at a Time

 

 

When Jorge Luis Borges Co-Wrote a Surreal Sci-Fi Noir Film: Invasión (1969)

“La ciu­dad es más que la gente.” So declares a char­ac­ter called Don Por­firio in Invasión, the debut fea­ture by Argen­tine direc­tor Hugo San­ti­a­go. The line is the film’s most mem­o­rable, not least because of the rever­sal it pulls on our expec­ta­tions. Say­ing that a city is real­ly its peo­ple must have been a some­what banal obser­va­tion even in 1969, when Invasión came out, but say­ing that a city is more than its peo­ple still sounds con­trar­i­an enough to be intrigu­ing. It’s even more com­pelling com­ing from Don Por­firio, a mas­ter­mind whose intense­ly abstract­ed man­ner and refined lit­er­ary dic­tion will remind some view­ers of no fig­ure so much as Jorge Luis Borges — and as well he might, since Borges co-wrote the script.

Anoth­er major con­trib­u­tor to Invasión’s screen­play was Borges’ long­time friend, occa­sion­al col­lab­o­ra­tor, and junior col­league in let­ters Adol­fo Bioy Casares. Any­one who’s read about their rela­tion­ship (as detailed in Bioy Casares’ tome of pub­lished diaries, sim­ply titled Borges) knows how deeply entan­gled it was with the streets of Buenos Aires, where both of them were born and raised. And any­one who knows Buenos Aires will rec­og­nize those streets onscreen in this film, despite the title card that calls it Aquilea. Echo­ing the name of Achilles, it offers a clue as to Borges and Bioy Casares’ clas­si­cal inspi­ra­tion for this project, which trans­pos­es the city under siege of Home­r’s Troy into mid-cen­tu­ry Latin Amer­i­ca, where a small group of resis­tance mem­bers orga­nize against an arriv­ing army of men­ac­ing white-coat­ed invaders.

Though Borges was­n’t exact­ly one for top­i­cal­i­ty in his own fic­ciones, it would­n’t be whol­ly unrea­son­able to make an alle­gor­i­cal read­ing of the film. It’s set in the year 1957, when Argenti­na was ruled by Pedro Euge­nio Aram­bu­ru, one of sev­er­al dic­ta­tors in the coun­try’s twen­ti­eth-cen­tu­ry his­to­ry. It came out dur­ing the dic­ta­tor­ship of Juan Car­los Onganía Car­ballo. And the 1976 mil­i­tary coup that put Jorge Rafael Videla in pow­er ban­ished it to an offi­cial non-exis­tence, seen only in the most under­ground screen­ings. It was­n’t until the nine­teen-nineties that Invasión was redis­cov­ered and made whole out of par­tial prints found in France, the coun­try to which San­ti­a­go had long since decamped. Now it can be seen on YouTube in one ver­sion with option­al Eng­lish and French sub­ti­tles, and anoth­er, high­er res­o­lu­tion ver­sion with French sub­ti­tles only.

View­ers today may be quick to notice the obvi­ous bud­getary lim­i­ta­tions, man­i­fest in odd-sound­ing foley work and the­atri­cal death scenes, but the cin­e­mat­ic vital­i­ty of its mix­ture of film noir, Nou­velle Vague, polit­i­cal thriller, and even sci­ence fic­tion remains unde­ni­able. (With the chas­es and explo­sions it man­ages, it may even par­tial­ly qual­i­fy as an action movie.) So does the atmos­phere of the real loca­tions — the streets Borges and Bioy Casares walked, as well as cafés, rail yards, and the cli­mac­tic foot­ball sta­di­um — that con­sti­tute its alter­nate­ly state­ly and des­o­late set­ting. It would be clichéd to say that the city itself becomes a char­ac­ter, but it would also prompt us to ask, which city, Buenos Aires or Aquilea? As with so many oth­er ques­tions about Invasión, there is no one answer.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Jorge Luis Borges: The Mir­ror Man, A Free Doc­u­men­tary on the Argen­tine Writer

Jorge Luis Borges, Film Crit­ic, Reviews King Kong (1933)

Alfred Hitch­cock Meets Jorge Luis Borges Borges in Cold War Amer­i­ca: Watch Dou­ble Take (2009) Free Online

Jorge Luis Borges Reviews Cit­i­zen Kane — and Gets a Response from Orson Welles

Las Calles de Borges: A Trib­ute to Argentina’s Favorite Son

Jorge Luis Borges Cre­ates a List of 16 Iron­ic Rules for Writ­ing Fic­tion

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

Watch Accurate Recreations of Medieval Italian Longsword Fighting Techniques, All Based on a Manuscript from 1404

Giv­en recent his­to­ry, the prospect of hun­dreds of young men meet­ing on Face­book, then trav­el­ing from around the coun­try to a cen­tral U.S. loca­tion might sound like rea­son­able cause for alarm. Yet a con­ven­tion fit­ting that descrip­tion had noth­ing to do with polit­i­cal vio­lence but, rather, a cel­e­bra­tion and appre­ci­a­tion of the name “Josh” (full dis­clo­sure: this writer did not attend). The gath­er­ing of the Josh­es in April 2021 in Nebras­ka could not have been more peace­ful, includ­ing its fin­ish­ing bat­tle royale, con­duct­ed with pool noo­dles.

The Josh­es had no con­cern for prop­er pool-noo­dle-wield­ing tech­nique, if there is such a thing. But groups of peo­ple who gath­er around the coun­try to stage medieval-style bat­tles in live-action role play­ing (LARP) games with weapons both real and fake might ben­e­fit from point­ers.

So, too, might those who chore­o­graph sword fights on stage and screen. Where can seri­ous his­tor­i­cal re-cre­ators learn how to wield a real blade in his­tor­i­cal­ly accu­rate com­bat? One resource can be found at Wik­te­nauer, a wiki devot­ed to col­lect­ing “all of the pri­ma­ry and sec­ondary source lit­er­a­ture that makes up the text of his­tor­i­cal Euro­pean Mar­tial arts (HEMA) research.”

The Fior di Battaglia (“Flower of Bat­tle”)—an Ital­ian fenc­ing man­u­al by Fiore de’i Liberi dat­ing from cir­ca 1404—offers rich­ly- and copi­ous­ly-illus­trat­ed demon­stra­tions of medieval Ital­ian longsword fight­ing tech­niques. In the orig­i­nal man­u­script, seen here and at The Get­ty, “the illus­tra­tions are inked sketch­es with gold leaf­ing on the crowns and garters,” notes the Wik­te­nauer entry. They dom­i­nate the text, which “takes the form of descrip­tive para­graphs set in poor Ital­ian verse, which are nev­er­the­less fair­ly clear and infor­ma­tive.” So clear, indeed, the brood­ing young men of Akademia Szermierzy—a Pol­ish group that recre­ates medieval sword-fight­ing techniques—can more than con­vinc­ing­ly mim­ic the moves in the video at the top.

Once they get going, after some req­ui­site pre-fight rig­ma­role, it’s impres­sive stuff, maybe already famil­iar to mod­ern fencers and cer­tain mem­bers of the Soci­ety for Cre­ative Anachro­nism, the LARP-ing orga­ni­za­tion of ama­teurs recre­at­ing every­thing from the Mid­dle Ages and the Renais­sance. But for those who think all live-action role-play­ing is the equiv­a­lent of the Bat­tle of the Josh­es (or off-brand Nazis run­ning through the streets in home­made armor), the sheer bal­let of his­tor­i­cal sword-fight­ing may come as a sur­prise — and maybe inspire a few more peo­ple to pull on the dou­blet and hose. See more medieval sword-fight­ing recre­ations from Akademia Szer­mierzy here, and the full text of the Fior di Battaglia here.

Note: An ear­li­er ver­sion of this post appeared on our site in 2021.

Relat­ed Con­tent: 

What It’s Like to Actu­al­ly Fight in Medieval Armor

A Close Look at Beowulf-Era Hel­mets & Swords, Cour­tesy of the British Muse­um

Renais­sance Knives Had Music Engraved on the Blades; Now Hear the Songs Per­formed by Mod­ern Singers

How Well Does Medieval Armor Actu­al­ly Stand Up to Medieval Arrows?: A His­tor­i­cal Re-Cre­ation Lets You See

The Last Duel Took Place in France in 1967, and It’s Caught on Film

Josh Jones is a writer and musi­cian based in Durham, NC. 

Behold the Gloriously Cheap 1970s Italian Knockoffs Inspired by Star Wars

When the first Star Wars movie came out, in 1977, cin­e­ma was the bet­ter part of a cen­tu­ry old, yet it had nev­er pro­duced a pop­u­lar-cul­ture phe­nom­e­non on such a scale. Cov­er­ing the result­ing explo­sion of pub­lic enthu­si­asm, the con­tem­po­rary media ini­tial­ly strug­gled to find ways to describe the pic­ture itself. “A cow­boy movie set in space, that’s Star Wars,” pro­nounces the announc­er in a TV news clip includ­ed in the new Nerd­writer video above. “It’s old-fash­ioned escapist enter­tain­ment, pure and sim­ple.” That may have been all the Ital­ian film indus­try need­ed to hear. The “spaghet­ti west­erns” of the pre­vi­ous dozen years had proven that it could prof­itably mas­ter an Amer­i­can genre; sure­ly it could do the same with a sim­i­lar one.

Among the results, alas, one looks in vain for A Fist­ful of Dol­lars, or even a Nava­jo Joe. Nerd­writer cre­ator Evan Puschak goes over var­i­ous instances of shame­less imi­ta­tion that char­ac­ter­ize the Ital­ian Star Wars clones, but you don’t have to take his word for it; you can, in fact, find some of these movies on YouTube.

Lui­gi Cozzi’s Star­Crash, for exam­ple, stars David Has­sel­hoff, The Spy Who Loved Me Bond girl Car­o­line Munro, and a Christo­pher Plum­mer putting in one of his most grandiose­ly vil­lain­ous per­for­mances ever; Aldo Lado’s The Humanoid, an even more shame­less knock-off, cred­its its direc­tor as “George B. Lewis.” Nor was Italy the only coun­try cash­ing in on the Star Wars craze: Puschak also shows clips from the Japan­ese film Mes­sage From Space by no less an auteur than Bat­tle Royale direc­tor Kin­ji Fukasaku.

Though many of these sec­ond-rate (at best) space operas made mon­ey, and some have even retained a cer­tain charm near­ly 50 years lat­er, they all come up against the fun­da­men­tal stingi­ness of the Cinecit­tà pro­duc­tion mod­el. “The truth is that you can’t imi­tate Star Wars with a low bud­get,” says Puschak. Despite all that’s been said about the myr­i­ad ways in which it taps into the pow­er of uni­ver­sal myth, “the spec­ta­cle, the immer­sion induced by its ground­break­ing spe­cial effects, was just as vital to the expe­ri­ence as the sto­ry and the char­ac­ters.” Hard as it may be for today’s young view­ers to believe, there was a time when movie­go­ers weren’t all that dis­crim­i­nat­ing about the real­ism, or even the plau­si­bil­i­ty, of the visu­als onscreen. After Star Wars, for bet­ter or for worse, they’d nev­er over­look vis­i­ble wires, unsteady lip-sync, or flat mat­te paint­ings so eas­i­ly again.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

How Post­war Ital­ian Cin­e­ma Cre­at­ed La Dolce Vita, and Then the Paparazzi

Quentin Taran­ti­no Lists His 20 Favorite Spaghet­ti West­erns

Cinecit­tà Luce and Google to Bring Italy’s Largest Film Archive to YouTube

Hard­ware Wars: The Moth­er of All Star Wars Fan Films (and the Most Prof­itable Short Film Ever Made)

How Ser­gio Leone Made Music an Actor in His Spaghet­ti West­erns, Cre­at­ing a Per­fect Har­mo­ny of Sound & Image

The Com­plete Star Wars “Fil­mu­men­tary”: A 6‑Hour, Fan-Made Star Wars Doc­u­men­tary, with Behind-the-Scenes Footage & Com­men­tary

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

How Leo Tolstoy Became a Vegetarian and Jumpstarted the Vegetarian & Humanitarian Movements in the 19th Century

Leo Tol­stoy is remem­bered as both a tow­er­ing pin­na­cle of Russ­ian lit­er­a­ture and a fas­ci­nat­ing exam­ple of Chris­t­ian anar­chism, a mys­ti­cal ver­sion of which the aris­to­crat­ic author pio­neered in the last quar­ter cen­tu­ry of his life. After a dra­mat­ic con­ver­sion, Tol­stoy reject­ed his social posi­tion, the favored vices of his youth, and the dietary habits of his cul­ture, becom­ing a vocal pro­po­nent of veg­e­tar­i­an­ism in his ascetic quest for the good life. Thou­sands of his con­tem­po­raries found Tolstoy’s exam­ple deeply com­pelling, and sev­er­al com­munes formed around his prin­ci­ples, to his dis­may. “To speak of ‘Tol­stoy­ism,’” he wrote, “to seek guid­ance, to inquire about my solu­tion of ques­tions, is a great and gross error.”

“Still,” writes Kelsey Osgood at The New York­er, “peo­ple insist­ed on seek­ing guid­ance from him,” includ­ing a young Mahat­ma Gand­hi, who struck up a live­ly cor­re­spon­dence with the writer and in 1910 found­ed a com­mu­ni­ty called “Tol­stoy Farm” near Johan­nes­burg.

Though uneasy in the role of move­ment leader, the author of Anna Karen­i­na invit­ed such treat­ment by pub­lish­ing dozens of philo­soph­i­cal and the­o­log­i­cal works, many of them in oppo­si­tion to a con­trary strain of reli­gious and moral ideas devel­op­ing in the late nine­teenth cen­tu­ry. Often called “mus­cu­lar Chris­tian­i­ty,” this trend respond­ed to what many Vic­to­ri­ans thought of as a cri­sis of mas­culin­i­ty by empha­siz­ing sports and war­rior ideals and rail­ing against the “fem­i­niza­tion” of the cul­ture.

Tol­stoy might be said to rep­re­sent a “veg­etable Christianity”—seeking har­mo­ny with nature and turn­ing away from all forms of vio­lence, includ­ing the eat­ing of meat. In “The First Step,” an 1891 essay on diet and eth­i­cal com­mit­ment, he char­ac­ter­ized the pre­vail­ing reli­gious atti­tude toward food:

I remem­ber how, with pride at his orig­i­nal­i­ty, an Evan­gel­i­cal preach­er, who was attack­ing monas­tic asceti­cism, once said to me “Ours is not a Chris­tian­i­ty of fast­ing and pri­va­tions, but of beef­steaks.” Chris­tian­i­ty, or virtue in general—and beef­steaks!

While he con­fessed him­self “not hor­ri­fied by this asso­ci­a­tion,” it is only because “there is no bad odor, no sound, no mon­stros­i­ty, to which man can­not become so accus­tomed that he ceas­es to remark what would strike a man unac­cus­tomed to it.” The killing and eat­ing of ani­mals, Tol­stoy came to believe, is a hor­ror to which—like war and serfdom—his cul­ture had grown far too accus­tomed. Like many an ani­mal rights activist today, Tol­stoy con­veyed his hor­ror of meat-eat­ing by describ­ing a slaugh­ter­house in detail, con­clud­ing:

[I]f he be real­ly and seri­ous­ly seek­ing to live a good life, the first thing from which he will abstain will always be the use of ani­mal food, because, to say noth­ing of the exci­ta­tion of the pas­sions caused by such food, its use is sim­ply immoral, as it involves the per­for­mance of an act which is con­trary to the moral feeling—killing.

[W]e can­not pre­tend that we do not know this. We are not ostrich­es, and can­not believe that if we refuse to look at what we do not wish to see, it will not exist.… [Y]oung, kind, unde­praved people—especially women and girls—without know­ing how it log­i­cal­ly fol­lows, feel that virtue is incom­pat­i­ble with beef­steaks, and, as soon as they wish to be good, give up eat­ing flesh.

The idea of veg­e­tar­i­an­ism of course pre­ced­ed Tol­stoy by hun­dreds of years of Hin­du and Bud­dhist prac­tice. And its grow­ing pop­u­lar­i­ty in Europe and Amer­i­ca pre­ced­ed him as well. “Tol­stoy became an out­spo­ken veg­e­tar­i­an at the age of 50,” writes Sam Pavlenko, “after meet­ing the pos­i­tivist and veg­e­tar­i­an William Frey, who, accord­ing to Tolstoy’s son Sergei Lvovich, vis­it­ed the great writer in the autumn of 1885.” Tolstoy’s dietary stance fit in with what Char­lotte Alston describes as an “increas­ing­ly orga­nized” inter­na­tion­al veg­e­tar­i­an move­ment tak­ing shape in the late nine­teenth cen­tu­ry.

Like Tol­stoy in “The First Step,” pro­po­nents of veg­e­tar­i­an­ism argued not only against cru­el­ty to ani­mals, but also against “the bru­tal­iza­tion of those who worked in the meat indus­try, as butch­ers, slaugh­ter­men, and even shep­herds and drovers.” But veg­e­tar­i­an­ism was only one part of Tolstoy’s reli­gious phi­los­o­phy, which also includ­ed chasti­ty, tem­per­ance, the rejec­tion of pri­vate prop­er­ty, and “a com­plete refusal to par­tic­i­pate in vio­lence or coer­cion of any kind.” This marked his dietary prac­tice as dis­tinct from many con­tem­po­raries. Tol­stoy and his fol­low­ers “made the link between veg­e­tar­i­an­ism and a wider human­i­tar­i­an­ism explic­it.”

“How was it pos­si­ble,” Alston sum­ma­rizes, “to regard the killing of ani­mals for food as evil, but not to con­demn the killing of men through war and cap­i­tal pun­ish­ment? Not all mem­bers of the veg­e­tar­i­an move­ment agreed.” Some saw “no con­nec­tion between the ques­tions of war and diet.” Tolstoy’s philo­soph­i­cal argu­ment against all forms of vio­lence was not orig­i­nal to him, but it res­onat­ed all over the world with those who saw him as a shin­ing exam­ple, includ­ing his two daugh­ters and even­tu­al­ly his wife Sophia, who all adopt­ed the prac­tice of veg­e­tar­i­an­ism. A book of their recipes was pub­lished in 1874, and adapt­ed by Pavlenko for his Leo Tol­stoy: A Vegetarian’s Tale. (See one exam­ple here—a fam­i­ly recipe for mac­a­roni and cheese.)

In her study Tol­stoy and His Dis­ci­ples, Alston details the Russ­ian great’s wide influ­ence through not only his diet but the total­i­ty of his spir­i­tu­al prac­tices and unique polit­i­cal and reli­gious views. Inter­est­ing­ly, unlike many ani­mal rights activists of his day and ours, Tol­stoy refused to endorse leg­is­la­tion to pun­ish ani­mal cru­el­ty, believ­ing that pun­ish­ment would only result in the per­pet­u­a­tion of vio­lence. “Non-vio­lence, non-resis­tance and broth­er­hood were the prin­ci­ples that lay at the basis of Tol­stoy­an veg­e­tar­i­an­ism,” she observes, “and while these prin­ci­ples meant that Tol­stoy­ans coop­er­at­ed close­ly with veg­e­tar­i­ans, they also kept them in many ways apart.”

Note: An ear­li­er ver­sion of this post appeared on our site in 2016.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Leo Tolstoy’s Fam­i­ly Recipe for Mac and Cheese

Watch Glass Walls, Paul McCartney’s Case for Going Veg­e­tar­i­an

Tol­stoy and Gand­hi Exchange Let­ters: Two Thinkers’ Quest for Gen­tle­ness, Humil­i­ty & Love (1909)

Leo Tolstoy’s Masochis­tic Diary: I Am Guilty of “Sloth,” “Cow­ardice” & “Sissi­ness” (1851)

Leo Tol­stoy Cre­ates a List of the 50+ Books That Influ­enced Him Most (1891)

Josh Jones is a writer and musi­cian based in Durham, NC. 

by | Permalink | Make a Comment ( 1 ) |

When Animals Were Put on Trial in Medieval Europe

Most of us twen­ty-first-cen­tu­ry urban­ites have a fair­ly sen­ti­men­tal view of farm ani­mals, pre­cise­ly because so many gen­er­a­tions have gone by since they’ve been part of our dai­ly lives. (In South Korea, where I live, the agri­cul­tur­al past remains just with­in liv­ing mem­o­ry. Per­haps that’s why so many restau­rants in Seoul adver­tise their meat with pic­tures of the ani­mals it comes from, some­times dressed in chef’s garb and cheer­ful­ly serv­ing up the very dish­es they’re about to become.) Things were dif­fer­ent in medieval Europe, where ani­mals were both a neces­si­ty and a poten­tial dan­ger. His­to­ry records many instances of seri­ous harm done to humans by hors­es, bulls, and espe­cial­ly pigs, who seem to have had a par­tic­u­lar ten­den­cy to turn on chil­dren.

Today we would describe the killing of a child as an inhu­man act, a term that, in these cas­es, applies more than fig­u­ra­tive­ly. As for the fate of the vio­lent­ly offend­ing ani­mal, we might imag­ine that it would be sum­mar­i­ly slaugh­tered, but between the tenth and eigh­teenth cen­turies — and espe­cial­ly in the fif­teenth and six­teenth cen­turies — it might well have been brought into a court­room first. Though oth­er crea­tures had already been sub­ject to legal pro­ceed­ings for quite some time, “the ear­li­est record­ed pig tri­al took place in Fonte­nay-aux-Ros­es, just out­side Paris, in 1266,” writes Alexan­der Lee at His­to­ry Today. “By the ear­ly fif­teenth cen­tu­ry, how­ev­er, they had become estab­lished prac­tice through­out Nor­mandy and the Île-de-France,” even­tu­al­ly spread­ing beyond the bor­der to Italy, Ger­many, and the Low Coun­tries.

“As con­tem­po­rary stu­dents of the Cor­pus iuris civilis knew, it was a basic prin­ci­ple of Roman law that ani­mals could not be cul­pa­ble,” Lee adds. “Lack­ing rea­son, they were inca­pable of har­bor­ing crim­i­nal intent and hence could not be guilty of a crime.” But in un-Roman north­ern France, “the admin­is­tra­tion of sec­u­lar jus­tice was still large­ly the con­cern of local seigneurs and was gov­erned pre­dom­i­nant­ly by cus­tom rather than statute.” Thus sus­tained, ani­mal tri­als served pur­pos­es beyond sim­ple pun­ish­ment. “For medieval peo­ple, the world was cre­at­ed by God in a very log­i­cal way, with ani­mals cre­at­ed first, in order to serve and help human beings who were cre­at­ed in the image of God,” says Uni­ver­si­ty of Liv­er­pool medieval Euro­pean mon­ster expert Dami­an Kempf, quot­ed in Pop­u­lar Sci­ence by Anne Ewbank. In that world­view, try­ing and exe­cut­ing a pig could “restore what was bro­ken.”

Unlike domes­tic ani­mals, accord­ing to Sonya Vatom­sky at JSTOR Dai­ly, destruc­tive mice, bee­tles, snails, wee­vils, and oth­er ver­min would be sent to eccle­si­as­ti­cal tri­bunals. “Despite being unlike­ly can­di­dates for Catholi­cism, such crea­tures were pun­ished with excom­mu­ni­ca­tion, not exe­cu­tion,” she writes, since cast­ing them out of God’s domain would allow humans to exter­mi­nate them with peace of mind. Vatom­sky also quotes econ­o­mist Peter T. Leeson’s the­o­ry that the Catholic Church tried more ani­mals when peo­ple got lax about tithing, with the aim of “bol­ster­ing cit­i­zens’ belief in the valid­i­ty of Church pun­ish­ments for tithe eva­sion.” Putting ani­mals on tri­al may now strike us as grotesque, but like any alien-seem­ing episode of his­to­ry, it also reveals the beliefs on which a past soci­ety oper­at­ed — a mode of analy­sis that gets one won­der­ing how far the mod­ern Unit­ed States is from giv­ing them the right to sue.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Why Ani­mals Look So Strange in Medieval Man­u­scripts

1,000 Years of Medieval Euro­pean His­to­ry in 20 Min­utes

The Aberdeen Bes­tiary, One of the Great Medieval Illu­mi­nat­ed Man­u­scripts, Now Dig­i­tized in High Res­o­lu­tion & Made Avail­able Online

A Free Yale Course on Medieval His­to­ry: 700 Years in 22 Lec­tures

Cats in Medieval Man­u­scripts & Paint­ings

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

European Intellectual History Since Nietzsche: A Free Online Course from Yale

Taught by his­to­ri­an Mar­ci Shore, “Euro­pean Intel­lec­tu­al His­to­ry Since Niet­zsche” sur­veys the sto­ry of mod­ern thought, from the late 18th cen­tu­ry to the late 20th.

Along the way, the course explores major trends in mod­ern Euro­pean thought: Marx­ism-Lenin­ism, psy­cho­analy­sis, expres­sion­ism, struc­tural­ism, phe­nom­e­nol­o­gy, exis­ten­tial­ism, anti-pol­i­tics, and decon­struc­tion. Intel­lec­tu­al fig­ures cov­ered in the course include Niet­zsche, Lenin, Kaf­ka, Freud, Husserl, de Beau­voir, Hei­deg­ger, Arendt, Adorno, Sartre, Girard, Fou­cault, Der­ri­da, and Hav­el.

You can watch all 25 lec­tures above. Or find them on YouTube and Apple Pod­casts. Explore the course hand­outs here.

“Euro­pean Intel­lec­tu­al His­to­ry Since Niet­zsche” will be added to our col­lec­tion, 1,700 Free Online Cours­es from Top Uni­ver­si­ties.

If you would like to sup­port the mis­sion of Open Cul­ture, con­sid­er mak­ing a dona­tion to our site. It’s hard to rely 100% on ads, and your con­tri­bu­tions will help us con­tin­ue pro­vid­ing the best free cul­tur­al and edu­ca­tion­al mate­ri­als to learn­ers every­where. You can con­tribute through Pay­Pal, Patre­on, and Ven­mo (@openculture). Thanks!

Relat­ed Con­tent

A Beginner’s Guide to Phi­los­o­phy: From Log­ic to Epis­te­mol­o­gy to Meta­physics

Hear Hours of Lec­tures by Michel Fou­cault: Record­ed in Eng­lish & French Between 1961 and 1983

A His­to­ry of Phi­los­o­phy in 81 Video Lec­tures: A Free Course That Explores Phi­los­o­phy from Ancient Greece to Mod­ern Times

Jacques Der­ri­da on Sein­feld: “Decon­struc­tion Doesn’t Pro­duce Any Sit­com”

by | Permalink | Make a Comment ( 1 ) |

2,800-Year-Old Bone Flute Unearthed in Troy May Have Been Played During Homer’s Time

Image by Mehmet Nuri Ersoy, via Twit­ter

The pro­lif­ic Hans Zim­mer scored Christo­pher Nolan’s films over the dozen years from Bat­man Begins through Dunkirk. From 2020’s Tenet onward, Nolan has employed the younger Swedish com­pos­er Lud­wig Görans­son. Just what dif­fer­ence this has made in the result­ing pic­tures is a mat­ter best left to the scruti­ny of the most obses­sive fans, but any view­er can hear how much Zim­mer and Görans­son dif­fer styl­is­ti­cal­ly. This past sum­mer, the siren song includ­ed on the sound­track of The Odyssey fea­tured one of the lat­ter’s par­tic­u­lar­ly notable choic­es: the use of an aulos, a dou­ble-reed­ed wind instru­ment much played back in ancient Greece.

Though Görans­son did­n’t have a gen­uine­ly ancient aulos on hand, of course, the sound pro­duced by the repli­ca proved evoca­tive enough. But just this year, as it hap­pens, a bone flute actu­al­ly dat­ing from the peri­od in which Homer wrote The Odyssey was unearthed from the archae­o­log­i­cal site of ancient Troy in mod­ern-day north­west­ern Turkey.

As Smithsonian.com’s Meilan Sol­ly writes, the past 160 years of dig­ging there have pro­duced “a pair of gold diadems, more than 100 two-han­dled wine gob­lets, and arrow­heads and weapons dat­ed to the Late Bronze Age, among oth­er arti­facts.” This 2,800-year-old flute isn’t just the first musi­cal instru­ment dis­cov­ered at the site, but also fur­ther evi­dence that Troy was­n’t the ghost town it was once assumed to be in the eighth cen­tu­ry BC.

As always when deal­ing with ancient arti­facts — and espe­cial­ly ones, as these pic­tures reveal, in a less-than-whole state — we should be care­ful with our terms. “Call­ing the object a flute is the exca­va­tors’ choice of word, and the type remains open,” says Ancient Ori­gins. While this new dis­cov­ery could poten­tial­ly be a real Greek aulos, “with­out hole counts or a pub­lished draw­ing, match­ing the Troy find to that design is pre­ma­ture.” Archae­ol­o­gists have unearthed sim­i­lar instru­ments else­where, dat­ing from dif­fer­ent peri­ods, but nev­er before has one emerged from the buried remains of a city so rich in leg­endary asso­ci­a­tions. To those in search of a deep­er under­stand­ing of antiq­ui­ty, the site con­tin­ues to sound a siren song of its own.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Hear What Homer’s Odyssey Sound­ed Like When Sung in the Orig­i­nal Ancient Greek

Bronze Age Britons Turned Bones of Dead Rel­a­tives into Musi­cal Instru­ments & Orna­ments

Hear a 9,000 Year Old Flute—the World’s Old­est Playable Instrument—Get Played Again

Hear a Recent­ly-Dis­cov­ered 12,000-Year-Old Flute That Musi­cal­ly Mim­ics the Sound of Rap­tor Calls

What Ancient Greek Music Sound­ed Like: Lis­ten to a Recon­struc­tion That’s “100% Accu­rate”

Hear the World’s Old­est Instru­ment, the “Nean­derthal Flute,” Dat­ing Back Over 43,000 Years

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.

When Salvador Dali Met Sigmund Freud, and Changed Freud’s Mind About Surrealism (1938)

The close asso­ci­a­tions between Sur­re­al­ism and Freudi­an psy­cho­analy­sis were lib­er­al­ly encour­aged by the most famous pro­po­nent of the move­ment, Sal­vador Dalí, who con­sid­ered him­self a devot­ed fol­low­er of Freud. We don’t have to won­der what the founder of psy­cho­analy­sis would have thought of his self-appoint­ed pro­tégé.

We have them record­ing, in their own words, their impres­sions of their one and only meeting—which took place in July of 1938, at Freud’s home in Lon­don. Freud was 82, Dalí 34. We also have sketch­es Dalí made of Freud while the two sat togeth­er. Their mem­o­ries of events, shall we say, dif­fer con­sid­er­ably, or at least they seemed total­ly bewil­dered by each oth­er. (Freud pro­nounced Dalí a “fanat­ic.”)

In any case, there’s absolute­ly no way the encounter could have lived up to Dalí’s expec­ta­tions, as the Freud Muse­um Lon­don notes:

[Dalí] had already trav­elled to Vien­na sev­er­al times but failed to make an intro­duc­tion. Instead, he wrote in his auto­bi­og­ra­phy, he spent his time hav­ing “long and exhaus­tive imag­i­nary con­ver­sa­tions” with his hero, at one point fan­ta­siz­ing that he “came home with me and stayed all night cling­ing to the cur­tains of my room in the Hotel Sach­er.”

Freud was cer­tain­ly not going to indulge Dalí’s pecu­liar fan­tasies, but what the artist real­ly want­ed was val­i­da­tion of his work—and maybe his very being. “Dalí had spent his teens and ear­ly twen­ties read­ing Freud’s works on the uncon­scious,” writes Paul Gal­lagher at Dan­ger­ous Minds, “on sex­u­al­i­ty and The Inter­pre­ta­tion of Dreams.” He was obsessed. Final­ly meet­ing Freud in ’38, he must have felt “like a believ­er might feel when com­ing face-to-face with God.”

He brought with him his lat­est paint­ing The Meta­mor­pho­sis of Nar­cis­sus, and an arti­cle he had pub­lished on para­noia. This, espe­cial­ly, Dalí hoped would gain the respect of the elder­ly Freud.

Try­ing to inter­est him, I explained that it was not a sur­re­al­ist diver­sion, but was real­ly an ambi­tious­ly sci­en­tif­ic arti­cle, and I repeat­ed the title, point­ing to it at the same time with my fin­ger. Before his imper­turbable indif­fer­ence, my voice became invol­un­tar­i­ly sharp­er and more insis­tent.

On being shown the paint­ing, Freud sup­pos­ed­ly said, “in clas­sic paint­ings I look for the uncon­scious, but in your paint­ings I look for the con­scious.” The com­ment stung, though Dalí wasn’t entire­ly sure what it meant. But he took it as fur­ther evi­dence that the meet­ing was a bust. Sketch­ing Freud in the draw­ing below, he wrote, “Freud’s cra­ni­um is a snail! His brain is in the form of a spiral—to be extract­ed with a nee­dle!”

One might see why Freud was sus­pi­cious of Sur­re­al­ists, “who have appar­ent­ly cho­sen me as their patron saint,” he wrote to Ste­fan Zweig, the mutu­al friend who intro­duced him to Dalí. In 1921, poet and Sur­re­al­ist man­i­festo writer André Bre­ton “had shown up unin­vit­ed on [Freud’s] doorstep.” Unhap­py with his recep­tion, Bre­ton pub­lished a “bit­ter attack,” call­ing Freud an “old man with­out ele­gance” and lat­er accused Freud of pla­gia­riz­ing him.

Despite the mem­o­ry of this nas­ti­ness, and Freud’s gen­er­al dis­taste for mod­ern art, he could­n’t help but be impressed with Dalí. “Until then,” he wrote to Zweig, “I was inclined to look upon the sur­re­al­ists… as absolute (let us say 95 per­cent, like alco­hol), cranks. That young Spaniard, how­ev­er, with his can­did and fanat­i­cal eyes, and his unde­ni­able tech­ni­cal mas­tery, has made me recon­sid­er my opin­ion.”

Note: An ear­li­er ver­sion of this post appeared on our site in 2020.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Sig­mund Freud Appears in Rare, Sur­viv­ing Video & Audio Record­ed Dur­ing the 1930s

When Sal­vador Dalí Gave a Sur­re­al­ist Lec­ture in a Div­ing Suit … and Almost Suf­fo­cat­ed (1936)

The Famous Break Up of Sig­mund Freud & Carl Jung Explained in a New Ani­mat­ed Video

How a Young Sig­mund Freud Researched & Got Addict­ed to Cocaine, the New “Mir­a­cle Drug,” in 1894

What Makes Sal­vador Dalí’s Icon­ic Sur­re­al­ist Paint­ing “The Per­sis­tence of Mem­o­ry” a Great Work of Art

Josh Jones is a writer and musi­cian based in Durham, NC. 

Watch Seoul’s 6,500-Year Evolution in a Mesmerizing 3D Animated Time Lapse

In this cen­tu­ry, few coun­tries have been as vis­i­bly suc­cess­ful as South Korea. Chi­na’s ver­tig­i­nous eco­nom­ic rise once absorbed vast amounts of news-media atten­tion, but its soft pow­er has com­par­a­tive­ly lit­tle reach across the wider world, at least in Eng­lish-speak­ing coun­tries. By this point, many if not most West­ern­ers haven’t just eat­en Kore­an food, but also dri­ven a Kore­an car, heard Kore­an pop music, or watched a Kore­an film or TV show. The result­ing sense of famil­iar­i­ty can prove decep­tive to those who even­tu­al­ly make the trip there, but it does, at least, mark an improve­ment on the scant knowl­edge of the place they had before. Not so long ago, they could say lit­tle with cer­tain­ty except this: South Kore­a’s got Seoul.

I first saw that pun on a T‑shirt in high school, long before I knew much of any­thing about Korea myself. Now, hav­ing lived there for more than a decade, I’ve been able to watch from the inside as the coun­try’s cap­i­tal has become an unlike­ly object of gen­er­al inter­est. As evi­dence, take the 1.2 mil­lion views already racked up by the new video from Latos Charts above, a 3D ani­mat­ed time lapse show­ing the evo­lu­tion of Seoul over six and a half often tumul­tuous mil­len­nia.

It reveals, among oth­er things, that the city did­n’t exist for most of the his­to­ry of Kore­an civ­i­liza­tion — but then, nei­ther did the coun­try. The post­war divi­sion of the penin­su­la into North and South has a kind of prece­dent in the war­ring king­doms that occu­pied it before its uni­fi­ca­tion by a series of states cul­mi­nat­ing in the 500-year rule of the Joseon Dynasty.

If you’ve watched one of the many pop­u­lar his­tor­i­cal “K‑dramas,” Joseon was most like­ly its peri­od set­ting. Now gen­er­al­ly regard­ed as the pre­de­ces­sor of mod­ern-day Korea, it pass­es in two min­utes of the time lapse, dur­ing which Seoul, then known as Hanyang, takes amid its geo­man­ti­cal­ly pro­tec­tive moun­tains more or less the shape it has today, at least north of the Han Riv­er. In fact, up until the sev­en­ties, there was no city to speak of south of the Han: the devel­op­ment of the more recent­ly musi­cal­ly sat­i­rized Gang­nam, lit­er­al­ly “south of the riv­er,” was part of the top-down push for eco­nom­ic devel­op­ment — in effect, hit­ting the fast-for­ward but­ton on his­to­ry — that fol­lowed the dev­as­ta­tion of the Kore­an War. That chap­ter of his­to­ry comes around eight min­utes into the video, after which looka­like high-rise com­plex­es start pop­ping up like mush­rooms after a mon­soon.

How­ev­er com­fort­able a lifestyle they’ve offered to mid­dle-class Seoulites, the sight of those apa­teu dan­ji unset­tles some West­ern observers, who encounter them in pho­tographs meant to depict the city as a kind of futur­is­tic dystopia. They exag­ger­ate, of course, but even some­one who appre­ci­ates Seoul as much as I do has to admit that, along­side its impres­sive qual­i­ties — the mag­nif­i­cent sub­way sys­tem, for exam­ple, extolled in the Not Just Bikes video above — the city has its prob­lems, as does the nation for which it stands. Under­stand­ing it in all its com­plex­i­ty requires first (even before learn­ing the Kore­an lan­guage) grasp­ing its sheer cen­tral­i­ty, greater than Toky­o’s to Japan or even Paris’ to France. To a great extent, South Korea has­n’t just got Seoul, it is Seoul. And maybe, if its promi­nence in the wider world con­tin­ues to grow, the pun­ning will even­tu­al­ly stop. In Kore­an his­to­ry, stranger things have cer­tain­ly hap­pened.

Relat­ed Con­tent:

Watch the Evo­lu­tion of Man­hat­tan Unfold in a Time­lapse Video, from 1600 to 2026

Watch the Evo­lu­tion of Paris Unfold in a Time­lapse Video, from 300 BCE to 2025

Watch Rome Rise, Fall, and Rise Again in a Three-Minute 3D Time­lapse

Why the Maps of Lon­don, Tokyo, New York, and Oth­er Major Cities Look the Way They Do

Time­lapse Ani­ma­tion Lets You See the Rise of Cities Across the Globe, from 3700 BC to 2000 AD

Learn the Kore­an Lan­guage with Hun­dreds of Episodes of Let’s Speak Kore­an Free Online

Based in Seoul, Col­in Marshall writes and broad­casts on cities, lan­guage, and cul­ture. He’s the author of the newslet­ter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Sum­ma­riz­ing Korea) and Kore­an Newtro. Fol­low him on the social net­work for­mer­ly known as Twit­ter at @colinmarshall.


  • Great Lectures

  • About Us

    Open Culture scours the web for the best educational media. We find the free courses and audio books you need, the language lessons & educational videos you want, and plenty of enlightenment in between.


    Advertise With Us

  • Archives

  • Search

  • Quantcast