Many, if not, most writÂers teach—whether litÂerÂaÂture, comÂpoÂsiÂtion, or creÂative writing—and examÂinÂing what those writÂers teach is an espeÂcialÂly interÂestÂing exerÂcise because it gives us insight not only into what they read, but also what they read closeÂly and careÂfulÂly, again and again, in order to inform their own work and demonÂstrate the craft as they know it to stuÂdents. Let’s take two case studÂies: exemÂplars of conÂtemÂpoÂrary litÂerÂary ficÂtion, both of whom teach at ColumÂbia UniÂverÂsiÂty. I’ll leave it to you to draw your own conÂcluÂsions about what their sylÂlabi show us about their process.
First up, we have Zadie Smith, author of White Teeth and, most recentÂly, NW: A NovÂel. In 2009, Smith lent her litÂerÂary senÂsiÂbilÂiÂties to the teachÂing of a weekÂly ficÂtion semÂiÂnar called “Sense and SenÂsiÂbilÂiÂty,” for which we have the full bookÂlist of 15 titles she assigned to stuÂdents. See the list below and make of it what you will:
Brief InterÂviews with Hideous Men, David FosÂter WalÂlace
Catholics, BriÂan Moore
The ComÂplete StoÂries, Franz KafÂka
Crash, J.G. BalÂlard
An ExperÂiÂment in Love, Hilary ManÂtel
ModÂern CritÂiÂcism and TheÂoÂry: A ReadÂer, David Lodge
The ScrewÂtape LetÂters, C.S. Lewis
My Loose Thread, DenÂnis CoopÂer
The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie, Muriel Spark
The LosÂer, Thomas BernÂhard
The Book of Daniel, E.L. DocÂtorow
A Room with a View, E.M. Forster
ReadÂer’s Block, David MarkÂson
Pnin, Vladimir Nabokov
The QuiÂet AmerÂiÂcan, GraÂham Greene
Smith’s list trends someÂwhat surÂprisÂingÂly white male. She includes not a few “writer’s writers”—Kafka, J.G. BalÂlard, and of course, Nabokov, who also turns up as a favorite for anothÂer RussÂian expat writer and author of AbsurÂdisÂtan, Gary ShteynÂgart. In a Barnes and Noble author proÂfile, ShteynÂgart lists two of Nabokov’s books—Pnin and LoliÂta—among his ten all-time favorites. Also on his list are Saul Bellow’s HerÂzog and Philip Roth’s Portnoy’s ComÂplaint. All three authors appear in a 2013 ColumÂbia course ShteynÂgart teachÂes called “The HysÂterÂiÂcal Male,” a class specifÂiÂcalÂly designed, it seems, to examÂine the neuÂroÂsis of the white (or JewÂish) male writer. With charÂacÂterÂisÂtic dark humor, he describes his course thus:
The 20th CenÂtuÂry has been a comÂplete disÂasÂter and the 21st cenÂtuÂry will likeÂly be even worse. In response to the hopeÂlessÂness of the human conÂdiÂtion in genÂerÂal, and the prospects for the North AmerÂiÂcan and British male in parÂticÂuÂlar, the conÂtemÂpoÂrary male novÂelÂist has been howlÂing angriÂly for quite some time. This course will examÂine some of the results, from Roth’s PortÂnoy and Bellow’s HerÂzog to MarÂtin Amis’s John Self, takÂing side trips into the unreÂliÂable insanÂiÂty of Nabokov’s Charles KinÂbote, the mudÂdled senilÂiÂty of MordeÂcai Richler’s BarÂney PanofÂsky and the someÂwhat quiÂeter desÂperÂaÂtion of David Gates’s JerniÂgan. We will examÂine the strateÂgies behind first-perÂson hysÂteÂria and conÂtrast with the alterÂnate third- and first-perÂson meshugas of Bruce Wagner’s I’ll Let You Go. What gives vitalÂiÂty to the male hysÂterÂiÂcal hero? How should humor be balÂanced with pathos? Why are so many proÂtagÂoÂnists (and authors) of JewÂish or Anglo extracÂtion? How have earÂly male hysÂterÂics givÂen rise to the “hysÂterÂiÂcal realÂism” as outÂlined by critÂic James Wood? Is the shoutÂing, sweaty male the perÂfect repÂreÂsenÂtaÂtion of our disÂasÂtrous times, or is a dose of sane introÂspecÂtion needÂed to make sense of the world around us? How does the change from earÂly to late hysÂterÂiÂcal novÂels reflect our progress from an entireÂly male-domÂiÂnatÂed world to a mostÂly male-domÂiÂnatÂed one? Do we still need to be readÂing this stuff?
I would hazÂard to guess that ShteynÂgart’s answer to the last quesÂtion is “yes.”
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
DonÂald Barthelme’s SylÂlabus HighÂlights 81 Books EssenÂtial for a LitÂerÂary EduÂcaÂtion
The Book TrailÂer as Self-ParÂoÂdy: Stars Gary ShteynÂgart with James FranÂco Cameo
Josh Jones is a writer and musiÂcian based in Durham, NC. FolÂlow him at @jdmagness


