John Fogerty once said that he conceived the opening bars of “Proud Mary” in imitation of Beethoven’s Fifth symphony. It’s an unusual association for a song about a steamboat, but it works as a classic blues rock hook. Most people would say, however, that the song didn’t truly come into its own until Tina Turner began covering it in 1969.
“Proud Mary” helped Turner come back after a suicide attempt the previous year. Her version, released as a single in January 1971, “planted the seeds of her liberation as both an artist and a woman,” Jason Heller writes at The Atlantic, bringing Ike and Tina major crossover success. Their version of the CCR song “rose to No.4 on Billboard’s pop chart, sold more than 1 million copies, and earned Turner the first of her 12 Grammy Awards.” See her, Ike, and the Ikettes perform it live on Italian TV, above.
It’s a sadly ironic part of her story that the success of “Proud Mary” also helped keep Turner in an abusive relationship with her musical partner and husband Ike for another five years until she finally left him in 1976. She spent the next several decades telling her story as she rose to international fame as a solo artist, in memoirs, interviews, and in the biopic What’s Love Got to Do With It.
The new HBO documentary, Tina, tells the story again but also includes Turner’s weary response to it. Asked in 1993 why she did not go see What’s Love Got to Do With It, Turner replied, “the story was actually written so that I would no longer have to discuss the issue. I don’t love that it’s always talked about… this constant reminder, it’s not so good. I’m not so happy about it.”
Like all musicians, Turner liked to talk about the music. “Proud Mary,” the second single from Ike and Tina’s Workin’ Together, came about when they heard an audition tape of the song, which they’d been covering on stage. “Ike said, ‘You know, I forgot all about that tune.’ And I said let’s do it, but let’s change it. So in the car Ike plays the guitar, we just sort of jam. And we just sort of broke into the black version of it.”
She may have given Ike credit for the idea, but the execution was all Tina (and the extraordinary Ikettes), and the song became a staple of her solo act for decades. Now, with Tina, it seems she may be leaving public life for good. “When do you stop being proud? How do you bow out slowly — just go away?” she says.
It’s a question she’s been asking with “Proud Mary” for half a century — onstage working day and night — a song, she said last year, that could be summed up in a single word, “Freedom.”
How Aretha Franklin Turned Otis Redding’s “Respect” Into a Civil Rights and Feminist Anthem
Watch the Earliest Known Footage of the Jimi Hendrix Experience (February, 1967)
How Giorgio Moroder & Donna Summer’s “I Feel Love” Created the “Blueprint for All Electronic Dance Music Today” (1977)
Josh Jones is a writer and musician based in Durham, NC. Follow him at @jdmagness
Such a great artist. Paved the way for so many at a great personal cost.
Actually, most people would say it’s a great song that survived a mauling by Old and Tina Turner. As an artistic statement, this cover ranks up there with Madonna’s cover of American Pie.
That’s not true
I disagree with your assessment. I would say that some people, not most people, feel that Ike and Tina Turner did not “maul” the song. They did a cover and did it in their inimitable style. Their cover is a classic. BTW, who is “Old” Turner?
I NEED TO correct my response. I would say that some people, not most people, feel that Ike and Tina Turner “mauled” the song. They did a cover and did it in their inimitable style. Their cover is a classic. BTW, who is “Old” Turner?
David, I agree with you 100%
The dancing is incredible, especially since they wore heels. Granted, not high heels, but difficult to dance in nevertheless.