CivÂiÂlizaÂtion moved past the use of casÂtles long ago, but their imagery endures in popÂuÂlar culÂture. Even young chilÂdren here in the twenÂty-twenÂties have an idea of what casÂtles look like. But why do they look like that? AdmitÂtedÂly, that’s a bit of a trick quesÂtion: the popÂuÂlar conÂcept of casÂtles tends to be inspired by medieval examÂples, but in hisÂtorÂiÂcal fact, the design of casÂtles changed subÂstanÂtialÂly over time, albeit slowÂly at first. You can hear that process explained in the Get to the Point video above, which tells the stoÂry of “star forts,” the built response to the “techÂnolÂoÂgy that endÂed the MidÂdle Ages.”
You may be familÂiar with the conÂcept of “motte and baiÂley,” now most wideÂly underÂstood as a metaphor for a cerÂtain debate tacÂtic irriÂtatÂingÂly prevaÂlent on the interÂnet. But it actuÂalÂly refers to a style of casÂtle conÂstructÂed in Europe between the tenth and the thirÂteenth cenÂturies, conÂsistÂing of a forÂtiÂfied hillÂtop keep, or “motte,” with a less defenÂsiÂble walled courtÂyard, or “baiÂley,” below. In case of an attack, the batÂtle could priÂmarÂiÂly take place down in the baiÂley, with retreats to the motte occurÂring when strateÂgiÂcalÂly necÂesÂsary. The motte-and-baiÂley casÂtle is a “great idea,” says the video’s narÂraÂtor, proÂvidÂed “you don’t have canÂnons shootÂing at you.”
CasÂtles, he explains, “were a reflecÂtion of armies at the time: build a big wall, keep the barÂbarÂians out.” But once the canÂnon came on the scene, those once-pracÂtiÂcalÂly imperÂviÂous stone walls became a seriÂous liaÂbilÂiÂty. That was definÂiÂtiveÂly proven in 1453, when “the Ottomans famousÂly batÂtered down the great walls of ConÂstanÂtinoÂple with their canÂnons. That brought an end not only to the 1500-year-old Roman Empire, but also to the MidÂdle Ages as an era entireÂly.” In response, casÂtle archiÂtects added dirt slopes, or glacis, at the edges, as well as cirÂcuÂlar basÂtions to deflect canÂnon fire at the corÂners — which, inconÂveÂnientÂly, creÂatÂed “dead zones” in which eneÂmy solÂdiers could hide, proÂtectÂed from any defensÂes launched from withÂin the casÂtle.
The soluÂtion was to make the basÂtions triÂanÂguÂlar instead, and then to add furÂther triÂanÂguÂlar strucÂtures between them. Seen from the side, casÂtles became much lowÂer and wider; from above, they grew ever pointier and more comÂplex in shape. SĂ©bastien Le PreÂstre, MarÂquis of Vauban, an army offiÂcer under Louis XIV, became the acknowlÂedged masÂter of this form, the trace italÂiÂenne. You may not know his name, but his designs made France “litÂerÂalÂly imposÂsiÂble to invade.” For sheer beauÂty, howÂevÂer, it would be hard to top the plans for star forts to defend FloÂrence in the fifÂteen-twenÂties by a mulÂti-talÂentÂed artist named MichelanÂgeÂlo. PerÂhaps you’ve heard of him?
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
LeonarÂdo da VinÂci Draws Designs of Future War Machines: Tanks, Machine Guns & More
How to Build a 13th-CenÂtuÂry CasÂtle, Using Only AuthenÂtic Medieval Tools & TechÂniques
A ForÂgotÂten 16th-CenÂtuÂry ManÂuÂscript Reveals the First Designs for ModÂern RockÂets
Based in Seoul, ColÂin Marshall writes and broadÂcasts on cities, lanÂguage, and culÂture. His projects include the SubÂstack newsletÂter Books on Cities and the book The StateÂless City: a Walk through 21st-CenÂtuÂry Los AngeÂles. FolÂlow him on the social netÂwork forÂmerÂly known as TwitÂter at @colinmarshall.
Indeed the Ottomans did take ConÂstanÂtinoÂple using a speÂcial canÂnon to breach the 1000 year old walls. A masÂterÂpiece of milÂiÂtary orgaÂniÂzaÂtion.
That canÂnon, howÂevÂer, was designed and built by a HunÂgarÂiÂan, perÂfectÂly ready to sell out ChrisÂtenÂdom for monÂey and fame.
The Ottomans ran a huge empire for a long time, based on a fair bit of reliÂgious tolÂerÂance. But techÂniÂcal innoÂvaÂtion wasn’t their strength. The weakÂness proved fatal.
EvenÂtuÂalÂly the cost/benefit ratio became too lopÂsided to make casÂtles and fortressÂes good investÂments. We’re startÂing to see the same thing with jets and drones.
GivÂen enough time, any techÂnolÂoÂgy becomes obsoÂlete. GivÂen the nature of milÂiÂtary techÂnolÂoÂgy, keepÂing it secret is paraÂmount. HowÂevÂer it is pracÂtiÂcalÂly imposÂsiÂble to accomÂplish. RestÂing on your lauÂrels is tanÂtaÂmount to acceptÂing defeat.
The thumbÂnail image is so incredÂiÂbly bad, and so ridicuÂlousÂly AI genÂerÂatÂed it bothÂered me enough to comÂment. Shame on you…