New Kindle Out, But Can You Read It at Night?

Before you get dissuaded by my original comments, please see my latest update down below.

As we mentioned earlier this week, Amazon unveiled its new Kindle this morning in NYC. The Kindle DX ($489) features a large screen (9.7 inches measured diagonally) and it's intended to make reading newspapers, college textbooks and PDFs a more user-friendly experience. Plenty of news outlets have provided coverage of the unveiling: Engadget, Gizmodo, Ars Technica, etc. And it's mostly positive. But I'm left wondering if the Kindle DX addresses the major problem with Kindle 2 ($359). If you spend some time on Amazon's Kindle discussion forum, you'll see that one of the longest threads (so far containing 857 posts) is devoted to complaints about the Kindle's light fonts and dark background -- a bad combo, especially when you try to read it at night. (Others have kvetched about it here.) I bought the Kindle 2, and really loved it in many ways. But I couldn't use it in lower light conditions. At night, the screen gets muddy, and the words don't pop off of the page. And that's a deal breaker for me. Meanwhile, with the same lighting, a traditional book reads perfectly well.  The major problem with the Kindle gets down to this: Users can't really customize the look & feel of the reading material. Yes, you can increase and decrease the size of the fonts. But you can't make the fonts darker (unless you know how to hack the darn thing). Nor can you make the background lighter. This one-size-fits-all approach is what Gutenberg gave us in the 15th century. (Sorry, don't mean to knock on Gutenberg.) It shouldn't be what Amazon gives us for  $359 in 2009. Could you imagine Apple serving this up? Hardly. And speaking of Apple, it may have its own e-book reader coming soon. According to PC Magazine, Apple may be rolling out the iPad ($699), which could be an e-book/internet reader and media player all rolled into one. For now, I'm waiting to see what Apple brings to market and hoping that Amazon finds religion. When they get the Kindle right, it will be great.

UPDATE: A year later, a new Kindle is out (see Wifi version here, and 3G wireless version here). The contrast is noticeably improved with this model. But, even better, Amazon now sells (separately) a case that has a built in retractable light. Taken together, you can now read the Kindle fairly well at night, under pretty much any light conditions. This Kindle I kept, and I'm a bigger fan than before.


by | Permalink | Comments (2) |

Support Open Culture

We're hoping to rely on our loyal readers rather than erratic ads. To support Open Culture's continued operation, please consider making a donation. We thank you!


Comments (2)
You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
  • Pete says:

    Maybe my experience with the Kindle 1 is unique to that device, but I don’t have your problem at all. I can read my Kindle anywhere I can read a book, and the week-long battery life makes computer-like competitors (e.g., iPad) uncompetitive. The Kindle 1 apparently renders text with more readable fonts, I understand.

  • Dan Colman says:

    Yup, I have heard it said that Kindle 2 was a bit of step backwards when it comes to the fonts.

  • Carol A says:

    Reading at night would be a No.1 priority for me – when do Amazon think most working people get to read?
    I am looking at the BeBook, it seems to have a much more “eye-friendly” screen.

  • Dell Desktop says:

    Reading at night is a yes. I do it all the time. You can’t read in the dark, if that’s what you’re asking. You have to have a light on. Reading in the dark is bad for your eyes anyways.

Leave a Reply

Quantcast