Theodor Adorno’s Critical Theory Text Minima Moralia Sung as Hardcore Punk Songs

in Music, Philosophy | August 12th, 2015

Adorno

With the possible exception of John Gray’s Straw Dogs, few works of philosophy confront the barrenness of human life in the modern world in bleaker terms than Theodor Adorno’s Minima Moralia. Taking its title from Aristotle’s Magna Moralia, or “The Great Ethics,” Adorno’s book subverts the classical idea of the good life as a realistic aspiration in a world dominated by totalitarian systems of control and inexorable, grinding logics of production and consumption. “Our perspective of life has passed into an ideology which conceals the fact that there is life no longer,” writes Adorno in his Dedication. The individual has been “reduced and degraded” by capitalism and fascism, flattened to mere appearance in the “sphere of consumption.”

Adorno’s book—a philosophical memoir of his experience as an “intellectual in emigration”—reflects his pessimism not only in its title but also in its subtitle: Reflections from Damaged Life. How little he could have suspected—and how much he likely would have despised—the kinship between his own postwar angst and the neurotic anger of the American hardcore punk generation to come some thirty-five years later. Take, for example these lyrics to Black Flag’s “Damaged,” from their 1981 album of the same name:

Right now look at me now
Look at me now
Just shadows
I’m just shadows of what I was
I just want another thing
I don’t even get by for that

One might make the case that Black Flag lyrics—and those of so many similar bands—play out Adorno’s thesis over and over: to quote a much less angry pop band from a later generation: “Modern Life is Rubbish.”

Seizing on these pessimistic parallels between punk rock and critical theory, filmmaker and artist Brian J. Davis recorded an EP of readings from five chapters of Adorno’s book, set to blistering hardcore drums and guitars. (Anyone happen to know who is on vocals?) Above, hear “They, The People,” and “This Side of the Pleasure Principle” and below, we have “UNmeasure for UNmeasure,” “Johnny Head-in-the-Air,” and “Every Work is an Uncommitted Crime.”

As you’ll note, Adorno’s titles allude to well-known works of art, politics, folk song, and theory and—as the publisher’s note in my Verso edition puts it— “involve irony or inversion,” primary rhetorical methods of his “negative dialectic.” The hardcore punks who picked up, however unconsciously, on Adorno’s disaffected critique may have eschewed his self-consciously literary approach, but they were no less masters of irony, even if their targets happened to be much more pop-cultural.

Punk rock Adorno comes to us from WFMU’s Kenneth S as examples of “academic theory… sung by people who can’t sing.” As Colin Marshall pointed out in a post yesterday, Goldsmith has made his own contribution to the genre, singing writings by Walter Benjamin, Ludwig Wittgenstein, and Sigmund Freud. And to even more humorous effect, we’ve previously brought you the work of M.A. Numminen, Finnish performance artist who turned Wittgenstein’s Tractatus into a bizarre comic opera.

For a much more serious look at Adorno and music—a subject he wrote passionately and controversially about—check out this post on his own avant-garde compositions, which turn out to be much less punk rock than one might expect given his social alienation and despondency.

Related Content:

The Theory of Walter Benjamin, Ludwig Wittgenstein & Sigmund Freud Sung by Kenneth Goldsmith

Ludwig Wittgenstein’s Tractatus Gets Adapted Into an Avant-Garde Comic Opera

Hear Theodor Adorno’s Avant-Garde Musical Compositions

Theodor Adorno’s Radical Critique of Joan Baez and the Music of the Vietnam War Protest Movement

Theodor Adorno’s Philosophy of Punctuation

Josh Jones is a writer and musician based in Durham, NC. Follow him at @jdmagness.

by | Make a Comment (3)




Comments (3)

  1. Angel Sanchez Borges says . . .
    August 12, 2015 / 9:53 am

    Greil Marcus wrote in Lipstick Traces that PIL’s Metal Box should be listened while reading Minima Moralia.

    This is a Vocaloid piece I did for singing philosophy:

    http://otrasmusicas.org/micromovies/KaraokeTeorico/

    & this YouTube Karaoke for you to choose Marxist quotes and sing over:

    http://otrasmusicas.org/theoreticalkaraoke/metalmarxism/

  2. Brian J Davis says . . .
    August 13, 2015 / 11:08 am

    Thanks for for digging this one up!

    As for the vocals, it’s my friend Dawn Lewis. The genesis for the project was, in fact, the Lipstick Traces quote. I included the passage in the insert for the single–Greil was quite happy to get credit. At the time, 2004-ish, I was making “fake album” multiples and this was the first time I decided to put actual music with one. I took some old hardcore vinyl out of storage, loaded some samples into Ableton 2. (Dag Nasty, Minor Threat, Cro-Mags, are the ones I remember.) I was a little drunk and because Dawn is classically trained she had to get drunk as well to downgrade her talent a bit. So two hours. Some samples. Some Scotch. There were two editions of 50 of this. It was a CD in silk screened 7inch packaging.

    Here’s the cover: http://brianjosephdavis.files.wordpress.com/2015/08/adorncoverscan.jpg

  3. RWordplay says . . .
    January 14, 2016 / 5:22 pm

    Simply wonderful. A special kind of brilliant.

Add A Comment