When the first Star Wars movie came out, in 1977, cinema was the better part of a century old, yet it had never produced a popular-culture phenomenon on such a scale. Covering the resulting explosion of public enthusiasm, the contemporary media initially struggled to find ways to describe the picture itself. “A cowboy movie set in space, that’s Star Wars,” pronounces the announcer in a TV news clip included in the new Nerdwriter video above. “It’s old-fashioned escapist entertainment, pure and simple.” That may have been all the Italian film industry needed to hear. The “spaghetti westerns” of the previous dozen years had proven that it could profitably master an American genre; surely it could do the same with a similar one.
Among the results, alas, one looks in vain for A Fistful of Dollars, or even a Navajo Joe. Nerdwriter creator Evan Puschak goes over various instances of shameless imitation that characterize the Italian Star Wars clones, but you don’t have to take his word for it; you can, in fact, find some of these movies on YouTube.
Luigi Cozzi’s StarCrash, for example, stars David Hasselhoff, The Spy Who Loved Me Bond girl Caroline Munro, and a Christopher Plummer putting in one of his most grandiosely villainous performances ever; Aldo Lado’s The Humanoid, an even more shameless knock-off, credits its director as “George B. Lewis.” Nor was Italy the only country cashing in on the Star Wars craze: Puschak also shows clips from the Japanese film Message From Space by no less an auteur than Battle Royale director Kinji Fukasaku.
Though many of these second-rate (at best) space operas made money, and some have even retained a certain charm nearly 50 years later, they all come up against the fundamental stinginess of the Cinecittà production model. “The truth is that you can’t imitate Star Wars with a low budget,” says Puschak. Despite all that’s been said about the myriad ways in which it taps into the power of universal myth, “the spectacle, the immersion induced by its groundbreaking special effects, was just as vital to the experience as the story and the characters.” Hard as it may be for today’s young viewers to believe, there was a time when moviegoers weren’t all that discriminating about the realism, or even the plausibility, of the visuals onscreen. After Star Wars, for better or for worse, they’d never overlook visible wires, unsteady lip-sync, or flat matte paintings so easily again.
Related Content:
How Postwar Italian Cinema Created La Dolce Vita, and Then the Paparazzi
Quentin Tarantino Lists His 20 Favorite Spaghetti Westerns
Cinecittà Luce and Google to Bring Italy’s Largest Film Archive to YouTube
Based in Seoul, Colin Marshall writes and broadcasts on cities, language, and culture. He’s the author of the newsletter Books on Cities as well as the books 한국 요약 금지 (No Summarizing Korea) and Korean Newtro. Follow him on the social network formerly known as Twitter at @colinmarshall.
Leave a Reply