HarÂvard has rolled out Week 2 of Michael Sandel’s course on JusÂtice. CourÂtesy of the course web site, here’s a synÂopÂsis of what you can expect from Episode 2. New lecÂtures are getÂting rolled out weekÂly. Check the HarÂvard web site for new addiÂtions.
Part 1 — PUTTING A PRICE TAG ON LIFE: Sandel presents some conÂtemÂpoÂrary casÂes in which cost-benÂeÂfit analyÂsis was used to put a dolÂlar valÂue on human life. The casÂes give rise to sevÂerÂal objecÂtions to the utilÂiÂtarÂiÂan logÂic of seekÂing “the greatÂest good for the greatÂest numÂber.” Is it posÂsiÂble to sum up and comÂpare all valÂues using a comÂmon meaÂsure like monÂey?
Part 2 — HOW TO MEASURE PLEASURE: Sandel introÂduces J. S. Mill, a utilÂiÂtarÂiÂan philosoÂpher who argues that seekÂing “the greatÂest good for the greatÂest numÂber” is comÂpatÂiÂble with proÂtectÂing indiÂvidÂual rights, and that utilÂiÂtarÂiÂanÂism can make room for a disÂtincÂtion between highÂer and lowÂer pleaÂsures. Sandel tests this theÂoÂry by playÂing video clips from three very difÂferÂent forms of enterÂtainÂment: Shakespeare’s HamÂlet, the realÂiÂty show Fear FacÂtor, and The SimpÂsons.