EndurÂing conÂspirÂaÂcy theÂoÂries aside, the 1969 moon landÂing (above) was a rousÂing sucÂcess for the govÂernÂment space proÂgram known as NASA. After a decade-long space race, durÂing which it seemed to all observers that the SoviÂets had the edge, the U.S. landÂed ApolÂlo 11–carrying Neil ArmÂstrong and Buzz Aldrin–at the Sea of TranÂquilÂiÂty on July 20, 1969. Nixon was presÂiÂdent, the VietÂnam War and its oppoÂsiÂtion raged, and Leonid BrezhÂnev helmed a stagÂnant SoviÂet empire.
On the great list of Cold War what-ifs, the near-miss of the Bay of Pigs is sureÂly numÂber one. But for all the space nerds out there, this one ranks pretÂty high: What if Aldrin and ArmÂstrong nevÂer made it back? This was, of course, a disÂtinct posÂsiÂbilÂiÂty, and one that the Nixon adminÂisÂtraÂtion preÂpared for. While we were told durÂing this last presÂiÂdenÂtial elecÂtion that Mitt RomÂney failed to write a conÂcesÂsion speech, William Safire, speechÂwriter for Richard Nixon, did write a speech in the event that ApolÂlo 11 couldn’t make the return trip. The speech, entiÂtled IN EVENT OF MOON DISASTER, is a someÂthing of a terse and poignant masÂterÂpiece. Below is an excerpt of Safire’s brief, hypoÂthetÂiÂcal address:
These two men are layÂing down their lives in mankind’s most noble goal: the search for truth and underÂstandÂing.
They will be mourned by their famÂiÂlies and friends; they will be mourned by the nation; they will be mourned by the peoÂple of the world; they will be mourned by a MothÂer Earth that dared send two of her sons into the unknown.
In their exploÂration, they stirred the peoÂple of the world to feel as one; in their sacÂriÂfice, they bind more tightÂly the brothÂerÂhood of man.
In ancient days, men looked at the stars and saw their heroes in the conÂstelÂlaÂtions. In modÂern times, we do much the same, but our heroes are epic men of flesh and blood.
OthÂers will folÂlow, and sureÂly find their way home. Man’s search will not be denied. But these men were the first, and they will remain the foreÂmost in our hearts.
For every human being who looks up at the moon in the nights to come will know that there is some corÂner of anothÂer world that is forÂevÂer mankind.
Would the space proÂgram have conÂtinÂued had these two brave pioÂneers died on the moon? CerÂtainÂly. But this moment of triÂumph would instead be remembered—like the ChalÂlenger disÂasÂter of 1986—as a moment of great loss and a very seriÂous setÂback for our forÂays into outÂer space.
Read the full speech here at LetÂters of Note.
Josh Jones is a docÂtorÂal canÂdiÂdate in EngÂlish at FordÂham UniÂverÂsiÂty and a co-founder and forÂmer manÂagÂing ediÂtor of GuerÂniÂca / A MagÂaÂzine of Arts and PolÂiÂtics.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
Michio Kaku Schools Takes on Moon LandÂing-ConÂspirÂaÂcy BelievÂer on His SciÂence FanÂtasÂtic PodÂcast
Dark Side of the Moon: A MockÂuÂmenÂtary on StanÂley Kubrick and the Moon LandÂing Hoax
First Orbit: CelÂeÂbratÂing 50th AnniverÂsary of Yuri Gagaran’s Space Flight