A friend of mine rails against the New YorkÂer’s weekÂly carÂtoon capÂtion conÂtest, insistÂing that while the readÂer-subÂmitÂted entries are uniÂverÂsalÂly bad, the winÂner is always the weakÂest of the lot.
I disÂagree, agog at peoÂple’s clevÂerÂness. Any line I come up with feels too obviÂous or too obscure. Unlike my friend, I nevÂer feel I could do betÂter.
CarÂtoon ediÂtor Bob MankofÂf’s recent TED Talk offers some key insights into what the magÂaÂzine is lookÂing for (inconÂgruity, disÂpoÂsiÂtionÂal humor, cogÂniÂtive mash ups), as well as what it’s not interÂestÂed in (gross-out jokes, mild child-cenÂtered canÂniÂbalÂism) He also cites forÂmer conÂtribÂuÂtor and author of my father’s favorite New YorkÂer carÂtoon, E.B. White on the futilÂiÂty of anaÂlyzÂing humor.
FreÂquent conÂtribÂuÂtor Matthew DifÂfee’s short satirÂiÂcal film Being Bob sugÂgests Mankoff ediÂtoÂrÂiÂal selecÂtions owe much to gut response (and a jerkÂing knee). Such intuÂition is hard won. Mankoff gleeÂfulÂly alludes to the 2000 rejecÂtion letÂters he himÂself received between 1974 and 1977, folÂlowÂing an uncerÂeÂmoÂniÂous disÂmissal from psyÂcholÂoÂgy school. Then, finalÂly, he got his first accepÂtance.
That accepÂtance letÂter is someÂthing to see.
Ayun HalÂlÂiÂday used Charles BarÂsotti’s New YorkÂer carÂtoon of a dancÂing bird as her highÂschool yearÂbook’s senior sayÂing. FolÂlow her @AyunHalliday
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
The New Yorker’s FicÂtion PodÂcast: Where Great WritÂers Read StoÂries by Great WritÂers
Improv with New YorkÂer CarÂtoonÂists
Einstein’s RelÂaÂtivÂiÂty: An AniÂmatÂed New YorkÂer CarÂtoon
