EarÂliÂer this week The New York Times pubÂlished an interÂestÂing disÂcusÂsion between philosoÂpher Michael Lynch and physiÂcist Alan Sokal on episÂtemic first prinÂciÂples, or, as Lynch put it in an earÂliÂer essay, the “ReaÂsons for ReaÂson.” To illusÂtrate the pracÂtiÂcal advanÂtage of obserÂvaÂtion and inducÂtive reaÂsonÂing in the forÂmaÂtion of beliefs, Sokal quotes a pasÂsage from James Robert Brown’s Who Rules in SciÂence?:
CerÂtain reaÂsonÂing patÂterns tend to proÂmote surÂvival; othÂers don’t. If Og reaÂsoned: “In the past tigers have regÂuÂlarÂly eatÂen peoÂple, but I’m sure this one will be quite friendÂly,” then very likeÂly Og is not your ancesÂtor.
Beliefs are imporÂtant. How we form them can have proÂfound conÂseÂquences for our own lives and–especially in a democracy–for the lives of the peoÂple around us. In this 15-minute video from the Richard Dawkins FounÂdaÂtion, SkepÂtic magÂaÂzine founder and ediÂtor Michael SherÂmer gives pracÂtiÂcal advice on how to sepÂaÂrate sense from nonÂsense when formÂing beliefs. The next time someÂone tries to conÂvince you of a tiger’s friendÂliÂness, do yourÂself a favor and take heed of what SherÂmer has to say.
If you would like to sign up for Open Culture’s free email newsletÂter, please find it here. It’s a great way to see our new posts, all bunÂdled in one email, each day.
If you would like to supÂport the misÂsion of Open CulÂture, conÂsidÂer makÂing a donaÂtion to our site. It’s hard to rely 100% on ads, and your conÂtriÂbuÂtions will help us conÂtinÂue proÂvidÂing the best free culÂturÂal and eduÂcaÂtionÂal mateÂriÂals to learnÂers everyÂwhere. You can conÂtribute through PayÂPal, PatreÂon, and VenÂmo (@openculture). Thanks!