CritÂiÂcal theÂoÂrist and musiÂcolÂoÂgist Theodor Adorno was a conÂtrarÂiÂan, almost conÂtraÂdicÂtoÂry figure—a comÂmitÂted MarxÂist thinker who was also a culÂturÂal elitÂist. AnyÂone who’s sat through a theÂoÂry class will know his name (most likeÂly through his semÂiÂnal text DialecÂtic of EnlightÂenÂment, writÂten with Max Horkheimer). For those who don’t, Adorno was an inteÂgral memÂber of what was called the “FrankÂfurt School,” a group of earÂly twenÂtiÂeth-cenÂtuÂry GerÂman scholÂars and social theÂoÂrists who were highÂly critÂiÂcal of both WestÂern capÂiÂtalÂism and SoviÂet comÂmuÂnism. Adorno’s work is wide-rangÂing, penÂeÂtratÂing, and, at times, abstruse to the point of nigh-uninÂtelÂliÂgiÂbilÂiÂty.
Despite Adorno’s hope for social transÂforÂmaÂtion, his influÂence is (by design) priÂmarÂiÂly in the acaÂdÂeÂmÂic and culÂturÂal spheres, and his criÂtiques of popÂuÂlar culÂture and music were scathing and someÂtimes just plain weird. He had a notoÂriÂousÂly irraÂtional disÂlike of jazz, for examÂple. (HisÂtoÂriÂan Eric HobÂsÂbawm said that his writÂing conÂtained “some of the stuÂpidÂest pages ever writÂten about jazz.”) Adorno also disÂliked “protest music,” as you can see from the interÂview above, in which he slams the folky, hipÂpy stuff for its “cross-eyed transÂfixÂion with amuseÂment” that renÂders it safe. Protest music, Adorno says, takes “the horÂrenÂdous,” the VietÂnam War in this case, and makes it “someÂhow conÂsumÂable.” Maybe Dylan felt the same way when he gave up his Woody Guthrie act and startÂed writÂing those brilÂliantÂly arcane, poetÂic lyrics.
But Adorno didn’t just preach the virtues of difÂfiÂcult art. He pracÂticed them. In addiÂtion to chamÂpiÂoning the twelve-tone music of Arnold SchoenÂberg, Adorno comÂposed his own music, for piano and strings. The three piano pieces above are his, someÂwhat remÂiÂnisÂcent of the most disÂsoÂnant pasÂsages in ModÂest MusÂsorgsky. PerÂformed by pianist StefÂfen SchleierÂmaÂchÂer, the pieces are titled “Langsame halbe—Immer ganz zart,” “Heftige Achtel,” and “Presto.”
A much longer, more subÂstanÂtial work is Adorno’s StudÂies for Strings in six moveÂments. MoveÂment one is above and moveÂment two below (hear part 3, part 4, part 5, and part 6). It’s chalÂlengÂing and often quite subÂlime lisÂtenÂing. The YouTuÂber who uploaded the music has seen fit to set it to a monÂtage of black-and-white images. I don’t know whether this hinÂders or helps your appreÂciÂaÂtion, but you may wish to leave the videos runÂning and lisÂten to each moveÂment while you work on othÂer things. Or betÂter yet, close your eyes and forÂget everyÂthing you know, don’t know, or think you know about Theodor Adorno.
Note: You can watch a lecÂture on the FrankÂfurt School here. It’s part of a Yale Open course on litÂerÂary theÂoÂry, which appears in our colÂlecÂtion of 700 Free Online CoursÂes.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
The Nazis’ 10 ConÂtrol-Freak Rules for Jazz PerÂformÂers: A Strange List from World War II
85,000 ClasÂsiÂcal Music Scores (and Free MP3s) on the Web
InterÂviews with SchoenÂberg and BartĂłk
Josh Jones is a writer and musiÂcian based in WashÂingÂton, DC. FolÂlow him at @jdmagness