AudiÂences today can’t get enough of hisÂtoÂry, espeÂcialÂly hisÂtoÂry preÂsentÂed as a podÂcast or a presÂtige teleÂviÂsion series. Best of all is the hisÂtorÂiÂcal presÂtige teleÂviÂsion series accomÂpaÂnied by its own podÂcast, curÂrentÂly exemÂpliÂfied by CherÂnobyl, HBO’s five-episode dramaÂtiÂzaÂtion of the events leadÂing up to and the afterÂmath of the titÂuÂlar SoviÂet nuclear disÂasÂter. “The mateÂrÂiÂal culÂture of the SoviÂet Union is reproÂduced with an accuÂraÂcy that has nevÂer before been seen in WestÂern teleÂviÂsion or film — or, for that matÂter, in RussÂian teleÂviÂsion or film,” The New Yorker’s Masha Gessen writes of the show. “SoviÂet-born AmerÂiÂcans — and, indeed, SoviÂet-born RusÂsians — have been tweetÂing and blogÂging in awe at the uncanÂny preÂciÂsion with which the physÂiÂcal surÂroundÂings of SoviÂet peoÂple have been reproÂduced.”
But along with all the praise for the accuÂraÂcy on CherÂnobyl’s surÂface has come critÂiÂcism of its deepÂer conÂcepÂtion of the time and place it takes as its setÂting: “its failÂure to accuÂrateÂly porÂtray SoviÂet relaÂtionÂships of powÂer,” as Gessen puts it, or to acknowlÂedge that “resÂigÂnaÂtion was the definÂing conÂdiÂtion of SoviÂet life. But resÂigÂnaÂtion is a depressÂing and untelegenic specÂtaÂcle. So the creÂators of CherÂnobyl imagÂine conÂfrontaÂtion where conÂfrontaÂtion was unthinkÂable.”
Among the chillÂing truths of the real stoÂry of the CherÂnobyl disÂasÂter is how many peoÂple involved knew beforeÂhand what could, and probÂaÂbly would, go wrong with the reacÂtor that explodÂed on April 26, 1986. But CherÂnobyl, adherÂing to “the outÂlines of a disÂasÂter movie,” instead pits a lone truth-teller against a set of self-servÂing, malevÂoÂlent highÂer-ups.
CherÂnobyl creÂator and writer Craig Mazin is not unaware of this, as anyÂone who has lisÂtened to the minisÂeries’ comÂpanÂion podÂcast knows. On each episode, Mazin disÂcussÂes (with Peter Sagal from Wait Wait…Don’t Tell Me!, inciÂdenÂtalÂly) the comÂpliÂcaÂtions of bringÂing such a comÂplex event, and one that involved so many peoÂple, to the screen three decades latÂer, and the inherÂent tradeÂoffs involved between hisÂtorÂiÂcal faithÂfulÂness and artisÂtic license. The video essay from Thomas Flight above comÂbines clips from the CherÂnobyl podÂcast with not just clips from CherÂnobyl itself but the real-life source footage that inspired the show. The six-minute viewÂing expeÂriÂence showÂcasÂes the often-astonÂishÂing recreÂations CherÂnobyl accomÂplishÂes even as it casts doubt on the posÂsiÂbilÂiÂty of ever truÂly recreÂatÂing hisÂtoÂry on the screen. But watchÂing creÂators take on that increasÂingÂly dauntÂing chalÂlenge is preÂciseÂly what today’s audiÂences can’t get enough of.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
A HauntÂing Drone’s‑Eye View of CherÂnobyl
200 HauntÂing Videos of U.S. Nuclear Tests Now DeclasÂsiÂfied and Put Online
A is for Atom: VinÂtage PR Film for Nuclear EnerÂgy
Based in Seoul, ColÂin MarÂshall writes and broadÂcasts on cities, lanÂguage, and culÂture. His projects include the book The StateÂless City: a Walk through 21st-CenÂtuÂry Los AngeÂles and the video series The City in CinÂeÂma. FolÂlow him on TwitÂter at @colinmarshall, on FaceÂbook, or on InstaÂgram.












