AskPhilosoÂphers puts real philosoÂphers at the serÂvice of the genÂerÂal pubÂlic. Have a big, lofty quesÂtion that only a proÂfesÂsionÂal philosoÂpher can tackÂle? They’ll answer it on the web. And now on the iPhone. This new, free app (designed by Amherst ColÂlege) lets you access their Q&A archive on the go. While waitÂing in line for a cofÂfee, you can chew over this kind of exchange:
QuesÂtion: If you fail to stop someÂthing bad hapÂpenÂing to you is it the same as being comÂplicÂit in the act?
Answer: There is a comÂpliÂcatÂed litÂerÂaÂture in moral phiÂlosÂoÂphy about how to draw the disÂtincÂtion between doing and mereÂly allowÂing harm and whether this disÂtincÂtion has moral sigÂnifÂiÂcance. WithÂout tryÂing to navÂiÂgate that deep intelÂlecÂtuÂal thickÂet, it is still posÂsiÂble to begin to address your quesÂtion. If I’m comÂplicÂit in doing someÂthing bad, for instance, harmÂing anothÂer perÂson, then it seems I share the aim of my accomÂplices in harmÂing someÂone else. I intend harm. By conÂtrast, if I mereÂly allow someÂone else to harm, I needÂn’t and typÂiÂcalÂly don’t intend harm. While not intendÂing harm, I may be indifÂferÂent to the harm. It depends. I may not be indifÂferÂent to the harm (more…)
