It’s time, again, for Edge.org’s annuÂal quesÂtion. The 2015 ediÂtion asks 187 accomÂplished (and in some casÂes celÂeÂbratÂed) thinkers to answer the quesÂtion: What Do You Think About Machines That Think?
John BrockÂman, the litÂerÂary ĂĽber agent and founder of Edge.org, fleshÂes the quesÂtion out a bit, writÂing:
In recent years, the 1980s-era philoÂsophÂiÂcal disÂcusÂsions about artiÂfiÂcial intelÂliÂgence (AI)—whether comÂputÂers can “realÂly” think, refer, be conÂscious, and so on—have led to new conÂverÂsaÂtions about how we should deal with the forms that many argue actuÂalÂly are impleÂmentÂed. These “AIs”, if they achieve “SuperÂinÂtelÂliÂgence” (Nick Bostrom), could pose “exisÂtenÂtial risks” that lead to “Our Final Hour” (MarÂtin Rees). And Stephen HawkÂing recentÂly made interÂnaÂtionÂal headÂlines when he notÂed “The develÂopÂment of full artiÂfiÂcial intelÂliÂgence could spell the end of the human race.”
But wait! Should we also ask what machines that think, or, “AIs”, might be thinkÂing about? Do they want, do they expect civÂil rights? Do they have feelÂings? What kind of govÂernÂment (for us) would an AI choose? What kind of sociÂety would they want to strucÂture for themÂselves? Or is “their” sociÂety “our” sociÂety? Will we, and the AIs, include each othÂer withÂin our respecÂtive cirÂcles of empaÂthy?
NumerÂous Edgies have been at the foreÂfront of the sciÂence behind the varÂiÂous flaÂvors of AI, either in their research or writÂings. AI was front and cenÂter in conÂverÂsaÂtions between charÂter memÂbers Pamela McCorÂduck (Machines Who Think) and Isaac AsiÂmov (Machines That Think) at our iniÂtial meetÂings in 1980. And the conÂverÂsaÂtion has conÂtinÂued unabatÂed, as is eviÂdent in the recent Edge feaÂture “The Myth of AI”, a conÂverÂsaÂtion with Jaron Lanier, that evoked rich and provocaÂtive comÂmenÂtaries.
Is AI becomÂing increasÂingÂly real? Are we now in a new era of the “AIs”? To conÂsidÂer this issue, it’s time to grow up. Enough already with the sciÂence ficÂtion and the movies, Star MakÂer, Blade RunÂner, 2001, Her, The Matrix, “The Borg”. Also, 80 years after TurÂing’s invenÂtion of his UniÂverÂsal Machine, it’s time to honÂor TurÂing, and othÂer AI pioÂneers, by givÂing them a well-deserved rest. We know the hisÂtoÂry. (See George Dyson’s 2004 Edge feaÂture “TurÂing’s CatheÂdral”.) So, once again, this time with rigÂor, the Edge Question—2015: WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT MACHINES THAT THINK?
The replies — 187 in total — feaÂture thoughts by BriÂan Eno, DouÂglas CouÂpÂland, Kevin KelÂly, Esther Dyson, and Daniel DenÂnett, among othÂers. You can access the comÂplete colÂlecÂtion of responsÂes here.
FolÂlow us on FaceÂbook, TwitÂter and Google Plus and share intelÂliÂgent media with your friends. Or betÂter yet, sign up for our daiÂly email and get a daiÂly dose of Open CulÂture in your inbox.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
Free Online ComÂputÂer SciÂence CoursÂes
Noam ChomÂsky Explains Where ArtiÂfiÂcial IntelÂliÂgence Went Wrong
Isaac AsiÂmov Explains His Three Laws of Robots















