PracÂtiÂcalÂly anyÂone could take one glance at Les DemoiÂselles d’AvÂiÂgnon and idenÂtiÂfy it as a PicasÂso, even if they’ve nevÂer seen it before and couldÂn’t say anyÂthing else about it. That alone goes some way to explainÂing why the paintÂing would end up ranked as the most imporÂtant artÂwork of the twenÂtiÂeth cenÂtuÂry, at least accordÂing to a study by UniÂverÂsiÂty of ChicaÂgo econÂoÂmist David W. GalenÂson. For that title it beat out the likes of Robert SmithÂson’s SpiÂral JetÂty, Richard HamilÂton’s Just what is it that makes today’s homes so difÂferÂent, so appealÂing?, MarÂcel DuchamÂp’s FounÂtain and Nude DescendÂing a StairÂcase, No. 2, and PicasÂso’s own GuerÂniÂca.
With Les DemoiÂselles d’AvÂiÂgnon, GalenÂson writes, “the greatÂest artist of the cenÂtuÂry iniÂtiÂatÂed the century’s most imporÂtant artisÂtic moveÂment. Art scholÂars debate whether the DemoiÂselles should be conÂsidÂered a Cubist paintÂing, but there is no quesÂtion that it difÂfered proÂfoundÂly from all of the art that preÂcedÂed it, and that it began the develÂopÂment of Cubism.”
PaintÂed in ambiÂtious response to HenÂri MatisÂse’s Le BonÂheur de vivre, its rejecÂtion of traÂdiÂtionÂal forÂmalÂiÂty and beauÂty shocked even PicasÂso’s forÂward-thinkÂing colÂleagues: “Not only did Matisse denounce the paintÂing as an attempt to disÂcredÂit modÂern art, but even Georges Braque, who would latÂer join forces with PicasÂso in develÂopÂing Cubism, was iniÂtialÂly so shocked by the paintÂing that he comÂpared PicasÂso to the fairÂground fire-eaters who drank kerosene to spit flames.”
Of course, there was also the matÂter of the paintÂing’s subÂject, five nude prosÂtiÂtutes in a Barcelona brothÂel. But as explained by Beth HarÂris and Steven ZuckÂer in the SmarthisÂtoÂry video above, the DemoiÂselles wasÂn’t always about the demoiÂselles alone. “In the origÂiÂnal sketchÂes, the women were focusÂing on a male that was includÂed, a sailor,” says ZuckÂer. “There was also a medÂical stuÂdent.” At some stages, HarÂris emphaÂsizes, the latÂter carÂried a human skull, a piece of proÂfesÂsionÂal equipÂment but also “a reminder of death, a memenÂto mori. And so there seems to be some tenÂsion here between the senÂsuÂalÂiÂty that the sailor is indulging in and a morÂalÂizÂing reminder that the pleaÂsures of life are short”: an unusuÂal perÂspecÂtive to be expressed by a 26-year-old, but then, PicasÂso wasÂn’t the usuÂal artist.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
ThouÂsands of Pablo Picasso’s Works Now AvailÂable in a New DigÂiÂtal Archive
How to UnderÂstand a PicasÂso PaintÂing: A Video Primer
Based in Seoul, ColÂin Marshall writes and broadÂcasts on cities, lanÂguage, and culÂture. His projects include the SubÂstack newsletÂter Books on Cities and the book The StateÂless City: a Walk through 21st-CenÂtuÂry Los AngeÂles. FolÂlow him on the social netÂwork forÂmerÂly known as TwitÂter at @colinmarshall.














