How does a movie become a “clasÂsic”? ExplaÂnaÂtions, nevÂer less than utterÂly subÂjecÂtive, will vary from cinephile to cinephile, but I would subÂmit that clasÂsic-film staÂtus, as traÂdiÂtionÂalÂly underÂstood, requires that all eleÂments of the proÂducÂtion work in at least near-perÂfect harÂmoÂny: the cinÂeÂmatogÂraÂphy, the castÂing, the editÂing, the design, the setÂting, the score. OutÂside first-year film studÂies semÂiÂnars and delibÂerÂateÂly conÂtrarÂiÂan culÂture columns, the label of clasÂsic, once attained, goes pracÂtiÂcalÂly undisÂputÂed. Even those who activeÂly disÂlike StanÂley KubrickÂ’s 2001: A Space Odyssey, for instance, would sureÂly agree that its every last audioÂviÂsuÂal nuance serves its disÂtincÂtive, bold vision — espeÂcialÂly that openÂing use of “Thus Spake ZarathusÂtra.”
But Kubrick didÂn’t always intend to use that piece, nor the othÂer orchesÂtral works we’ve come to closeÂly assoÂciate with mankind’s venÂtures into realms beyond Earth and strugÂgles with intelÂliÂgence of its own invenÂtion. AccordÂing to Jason KotÂtke, Kubrick had comÂmisÂsioned an origÂiÂnal score from A StreetÂcar Named Desire, SparÂtaÂcus, CleopaÂtra, and Who’s Afraid of VirÂginia Woolf comÂposÂer Alex North.
At the top of the post, you can see 2001’s openÂing with North’s music, and below you can hear 38 minÂutes of his score on SpoÂtiÂfy. As to the quesÂtion of why Kubrick stuck instead with the temÂpoÂrary score of Strauss, Ligeti, and KhatchÂaÂturiÂan he’d used in editÂing, KotÂtke quotes from Michel CimenÂt’s interÂview with the filmÂmakÂer:
HowÂevÂer good our best film comÂposers may be, they are not a Beethoven, a Mozart or a Brahms. Why use music which is less good when there is such a mulÂtiÂtude of great orchesÂtral music availÂable from the past and from our own time? [ … ] Although [North] and I went over the picÂture very careÂfulÂly, and he lisÂtened to these temÂpoÂrary tracks and agreed that they worked fine and would serve as a guide to the musiÂcal objecÂtives of each sequence he, nevÂerÂtheÂless, wrote and recordÂed a score which could not have been more alien to the music we had lisÂtened to, and much more seriÂous than that, a score which, in my opinÂion, was comÂpleteÂly inadÂeÂquate for the film.
North didÂn’t find out about KubrickÂ’s choice until 2001’s New York City preÂmiere. Not an enviÂable sitÂuÂaÂtion, cerÂtainÂly, but not the worst thing that ever hapÂpened to a colÂlabÂoÂraÂtor who failed to rise to the direcÂtor’s expecÂtaÂtions.
For more Kubrick and clasÂsiÂcal music, see our recent post: The ClasÂsiÂcal Music in StanÂley Kubrick’s Films: LisÂten to a Free, 4 Hour Playlist
If you would like to supÂport the misÂsion of Open CulÂture, conÂsidÂer makÂing a donaÂtion to our site. It’s hard to rely 100% on ads, and your conÂtriÂbuÂtions will help us conÂtinÂue proÂvidÂing the best free culÂturÂal and eduÂcaÂtionÂal mateÂriÂals to learnÂers everyÂwhere. You can conÂtribute through PayÂPal, PatreÂon, and VenÂmo (@openculture). Thanks!
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
4,000+ Free Movies Online: Great ClasÂsics, Indies, Noir, WestÂerns, DocÂuÂmenÂtaries & More1966 Film Explores the MakÂing of Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey (and Our High-Tech Future)
James Cameron RevisÂits the MakÂing of Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey
Rare 1960s Audio: StanÂley Kubrick’s Big InterÂview with The New YorkÂer
ColÂin MarÂshall hosts and proÂduces NoteÂbook on Cities and CulÂture and writes essays on cities, lanÂguage, Asia, and men’s style. He’s at work on a book about Los AngeÂles, A Los AngeÂles Primer. FolÂlow him on TwitÂter at @colinmarshall or on FaceÂbook.

