How could David Byrne nevÂer have givÂen a comÂmenceÂment address before? As an expeÂriÂenced pubÂlic speakÂer, a well-known creÂator who has carved out his own culÂturÂal niche, an advoÂcate of things (such as cycling) beloved among world-changÂing young peoÂple, the founder of a band with a surÂprisÂing mulÂti-genÂerÂaÂtional appeal, and a man with no small comÂmand of PowÂerÂpoint, he’d seem to make an appealÂing choice indeed. His first comÂmenceÂment address ever came this year at the ColumÂbia UniÂverÂsiÂty School of the Arts, and, viewÂable from 1:17:00 in the video above, it has cerÂtainÂly made an impact in the interÂnet. The mesÂsage some grads and fans have takÂen away? “If you chose a career in the arts,” as the New YorkÂer’s Rachel Arons puts it, “you are, basiÂcalÂly, screwed.”
“A pie chart, based on 2011 data, showed that only three per cent of film and theÂatre grads, and five per cent of writÂing and visuÂal-arts grads, end up workÂing in their areas of conÂcenÂtraÂtion,” she writes of the visuÂal aids delivÂerÂing Byrne’s grim iniÂtial mesÂsage. “A subÂseÂquent bar graph showed that, accordÂing to those stats, fourÂteen writÂing and fourÂteen ColumÂbia visuÂal-arts gradÂuÂates will go on to careers in their fields, and eight theÂatre and eight film grads will go on to careers in theirs.” But firstÂhand reports from the cerÂeÂmoÂny don’t describe a too terÂriÂbly shakÂen ColumÂbia gradÂuÂatÂing class, and even Byrne took pains to emphaÂsize, or at least emphatÂiÂcalÂly imply, that truÂly worthÂwhile careers — such as, I would say, his own — lay outÂside, or in between, or at the interÂsecÂtion of, definÂable fields. And why would you want to work in the same field you studÂied, anyÂway? To paraÂphrase someÂthing Byrne’s friend and colÂlabÂoÂraÂtor BriÂan Eno said about techÂnolÂoÂgy, once a whole major has built up around a purÂsuit, it’s probÂaÂbly not the most interÂestÂing thing to be doing anyÂmore.
RelatÂed ConÂtent:
David Byrne: How ArchiÂtecÂture Helped Music Evolve
David Byrne: From TalkÂing Heads FrontÂman to LeadÂing Urban Cyclist
David Byrne Gives Us the LowÂdown on How Music Works (with NeuÂroÂsciÂenÂtist Daniel LevÂitin)
How David Byrne and BriÂan Eno Make Music TogethÂer: A Short DocÂuÂmenÂtary
ColÂin MarÂshall hosts and proÂduces NoteÂbook on Cities and CulÂture and writes essays on litÂerÂaÂture, film, cities, Asia, and aesÂthetÂics. He’s at work on a book about Los AngeÂles, A Los AngeÂles Primer. FolÂlow him on TwitÂter at @colinmarshall.
.



