…I would like not to underÂesÂtiÂmate the valÂue of the world view which is the result of sciÂenÂtifÂic effort. We have been led to imagÂine all sorts of things infiÂniteÂly more marÂvelous than the imagÂinÂings of poets and dreamÂers of the past.
- Richard FeynÂman
In 1955, theÂoÂretÂiÂcal physiÂcist Richard FeynÂman gave a talk on the valÂue of sciÂence to memÂbers of the NationÂal AcadÂeÂmy of SciÂences at at CalÂtech UniÂverÂsiÂty.
In the wake of the destrucÂtion of HiroshiÂma and NagasaÂki, his involveÂment with the ManÂhatÂtan Project had been cause for seriÂous depresÂsion and soul searchÂing.
He conÂcludÂed that the purÂsuit of sciÂenÂtifÂic knowlÂedge remained valuÂable to sociÂety, even though such knowlÂedge comes withÂout operÂatÂing instrucÂtions, and thus can be put to evil purÂposÂes.
In the CalÂtech speech, he citÂed the life improvÂing techÂnoÂlogÂiÂcal and medÂical breakÂthroughs that are the result of sciÂenÂtifÂic exploÂrations, as well as the sciÂenÂtifÂic fieldÂ’s alleÂgiance to the conÂcept that we must be free to disÂsent, quesÂtion, and disÂcuss:
If we supÂpress all disÂcusÂsion, all critÂiÂcism, proÂclaimÂing “This is the answer, my friends; man is saved!” we will doom humanÂiÂty for a long time to the chains of authorÂiÂty, conÂfined to the limÂits of our present imagÂiÂnaÂtion.
(This strikes a proÂfound chord in 2022, rememÂberÂing how some extremeÂly vocal politiÂcians and citÂiÂzens took changÂing pubÂlic health manÂdates as eviÂdence of conÂspirÂaÂcy, rather than an ever-deepÂenÂing sciÂenÂtifÂic underÂstandÂing of how an unfaÂmilÂiar virus was operÂatÂing.)
Any child with an interÂest in STEM will be gratÂiÂfied to learn that FeynÂman also found much to admire in “the fun …which some peoÂple get from readÂing and learnÂing and thinkÂing about (sciÂence), and which othÂers get from workÂing in it.
ThroughÂout his speech, he refrained from techÂniÂcal jarÂgon, using lanÂguage that those whose pasÂsions skew more toward the arts can underÂstand to invoke the expeÂriÂence of sciÂenÂtifÂic disÂcovÂery.
His medÂiÂtaÂtions conÂcernÂing the interÂconÂnectÂedÂness between every molÂeÂcule “stuÂpidÂly mindÂing its own busiÂness” and everyÂthing else in the known uniÂverse, includÂing himÂself, a human standÂing beside the sea, tryÂing to make sense of it all, is of a piece with ShakeÂspeare and Walt WhitÂman.
UntiÂtled Ode to the WonÂder of Life
by Richard FeynÂman
I stand at the seashore, alone, and start to think.
There are the rushÂing waves
mounÂtains of molÂeÂcules
each stuÂpidÂly mindÂing its own busiÂness
trilÂlions apart
yet formÂing white surf in uniÂson.
Ages on ages before any eyes could see
year after year
thunÂderÂousÂly poundÂing the shore as now.
For whom, for what?
On a dead planÂet
with no life to enterÂtain.
NevÂer at rest
torÂtured by enerÂgy
wastÂed prodiÂgiousÂly by the sun
poured into space.
A mite makes the sea roar.
Deep in the sea
all molÂeÂcules repeat
the patÂterns of one anothÂer
till comÂplex new ones are formed.
They make othÂers like themÂselves
and a new dance starts.
GrowÂing in size and comÂplexÂiÂty
livÂing things
massÂes of atoms
DNA, proÂtein
dancÂing a patÂtern ever more intriÂcate.
Out of the craÂdle
onto dry land
here it is
standÂing: atoms with conÂsciousÂness;
matÂter with curiosÂiÂty.
Stands at the sea,
wonÂders at wonÂderÂing: I
a uniÂverse of atoms
an atom in the uniÂverse
The MarÂginÂaÂlian’s (forÂmerÂly Brain PickÂings) Maria PopoÂva seizes on this interÂlude for the final installÂment of her video series, The UniÂverse in Verse, above, colÂlabÂoÂratÂing with aniÂmaÂtor KelÂli AnderÂson on a “perÂspecÂtive-broadÂenÂing, mind-deepÂenÂing” visuÂal interÂpreÂtaÂtion of Feynman’s excerptÂed remarks.
FlowÂing under and around Feynman’s narÂraÂtion is an origÂiÂnal comÂpoÂsiÂtion by celÂlist Yo-Yo Ma, whose renown in the field of music is on par with Feynman’s in physics, and who notes in the introÂducÂtion to The Quotable FeynÂman:
While he paid close attenÂtion to probÂlems we face and genÂerÂate, he also knew that humans are a subÂset of nature, and nature held for him the greatÂest fasÂciÂnaÂtion — for the imagÂiÂnaÂtion of nature is far, far greater than the imagÂiÂnaÂtion of man, and nature guards her secrets jealÂousÂly.
Read Feynman’s comÂplete speech to the NationÂal AcadÂeÂmy of SciÂences at at CalÂtech UniÂverÂsiÂty here.
Watch all nine chapÂters of The UniÂverse in Verse here.
via The MarÂginÂaÂlian
RelatÂed ConÂtent
The “FeynÂman TechÂnique” for StudyÂing EffecÂtiveÂly: An AniÂmatÂed Primer
Richard Feynman’s “Lost LecÂture:” An AniÂmatÂed Retelling
Richard Feynman’s “NoteÂbook TechÂnique” Will Help You Learn Any Subject–at School, at Work, or in Life
Richard Feynman’s TechÂnique for LearnÂing SomeÂthing New: An AniÂmatÂed IntroÂducÂtion
The FeynÂman LecÂtures on Physics, The Most PopÂuÂlar Physics Book Ever WritÂten, Is Now ComÂpleteÂly Online
What IgnitÂed Richard Feynman’s Love of SciÂence Revealed in an AniÂmatÂed Video
- Ayun HalÂlÂiÂday is the Chief PriÂmaÂtolÂoÂgist of the East VilÂlage Inky zine and author, most recentÂly, of CreÂative, Not Famous: The Small PotaÂto ManÂiÂfesto. FolÂlow her @AyunHalliday.